2 upvotes, 0 direct replies (showing 0)
View submission: Too harsh a punishment?
By jaysus that's harsh.
Punishments 2 and 3 are far enough for what she's done. It was an accident, she didn't maliciously break it. Ground her and make her replace the stool, that way you're punishing her actions, and she's replacing what she broke so the 7 year old will have her present back.
Taking away the opportunity to meet an idol is frankly ridiculous, she may never have the same opportunity again and the bitterness she will feel will last a very long time.
There's nothing here!