12 upvotes, 0 direct replies (showing 0)
View submission: Too harsh a punishment?
Maybe there's more to this story, but it seems like she wasn't doing anything malicious, she was just being careless. She wasn't trying to break it was she? Rather she was using it for a task, albeit inappropriately? Those first two punishments are wildly harsh. Seems reasonable to ask her to replace it with her money since she broke something that didn't belong to her.
I'm not going to lie, my knee-jerk here was to feel indignation on your older daughter's behalf, so I can only imagine how she will feel, hopefully you can approach this calmly and fairly.
There's nothing here!