2010-12-14 13:36:05
By Tom Geoghegan BBC News Magazine
Toby Ord is a university researcher earning not much more than the average
salary. So why is he giving away 1m over his lifetime to help address global
poverty?
When Facebook founder and billionaire Mark Zuckerberg pledged to give away most
of his wealth during his lifetime, some British commentators bemoaned the lack
of philanthropy on this side of the Atlantic.
But an academic at Oxford University is living off little more than 300 a
month in an act of charity-giving that is arguably more impressive than those
of Zuckerberg, Gates, Buffett and co.
Toby Ord, 31, has in the past year given more than a third of his earnings,
10,000, to charities working in the poorest countries. He also gave away
15,000 of savings, as the start of his pledge to give away 1m over his
lifetime.
Toby Ord's lifestyle
Toby Ord
holidays
And he's started a campaign to recruit, Bill Gates-style, other people to give
up at least 10% of their lifetime's earnings in the same way. A year on, 64
people have joined his movement Giving What We Can and pledged 14m.
Given his personal sacrifice, it's difficult not to feel rather intrigued about
the kind of lifestyle he can maintain while so much of his earnings is going
elsewhere.
And heading to Oxford to find out, there's a fleeting thought that we'll be
sharing tea bags in a caravan parked on the banks of the Thames.
Instead, the Ord household inhabits a rented one-bedroom flat in a beautiful
sandstone house in the heart of the city. But the interior is as modest as the
exterior is glorious, furnished sparingly in a style reminiscent of student
digs. There is no television, through choice rather than hardship, but plenty
of books and DVDs.
The only signs of indulgence are the two Mac computers, for Ord and his wife,
although as he points out, they are used so much that the cost works out at a
few pence per hour. And he has an iPhone, which also helps him work.
Giving away a tenth of one's earnings is something most people in the UK can
achieve without having to make much of a sacrifice, says Ord, who was born and
raised in Melbourne, Australia.
Graphic showing his monthly spending
"That's probably surprising because if you did a survey of 100 people, 99 would
say they couldn't.
"When I was earning 14,000 as a student, I found I was in the richest 4% in
the world, even adjusting for how much further money goes in developing
countries.
"Giving away 10% of that, I found that I would still be in the top 5%. So while
it can seem impossible to live on less, if your employer was to suddenly pay
you less, you would get by somehow."
Ord gives away much more than a tenth. A year ago, he vowed to give away
everything he earned above 20,000 and his wife, Bernadette Young, a medical
doctor in the NHS, set a target of 25,000. After his first year, he has
lowered his personal allowance to 18,000.
Ultimately, there weren't any big sacrifices, he says, and they still maintain
a reasonable middle-class existence.
"What's really important in our lives is spending time together, chatting with
our close friends and reading beautiful books and listening to beautiful music,
and we're really lucky to live in a beautiful place and there are lots of
stimulating cultural activities around. With all that you can't really ask for
much more.
"I've also changed the way I look at the world. I don't want more stuff. If
someone said to me 'Here's one thousand pounds' and I had to spend it on myself
I would feel anxious about that because I just want to help people more and it
would be a very frustrating time."
Toby Ord's house Ord lives in a rented flat in Oxford
He goes out for dinner about once a fortnight and for coffee about once a week.
In the past year he spent 5,000 on rent to his employer and landlord, Balliol
College. He kept 4,000 to live on and pay the bills, while still having enough
to spend on a week's holiday in France and Italy, and put some away to buy a
house.
Incidentally, in 10 years, Ord and his wife, who have no children, will have
given away a sum that equals the average price of a house in the UK, just at a
time when they will hope to have bought one themselves.
"When it began, I would be down in the supermarket agonising about whether to
buy a more expensive cereal or not but I realise that's a road to a nervous
breakdown and that it was much more sensible to work out at the start what you
can live on [give away the rest in a lump sum] and then after a year readjust -
can I live on less, am I pushing it too hard - instead of perpetually agonising
about it."
It was while he was studying for a masters degree in philosophy that Ord came
across the idea of sacrificing luxuries in order to save a life. He estimated
that over his own lifetime he would need about 500,000 to live comfortably,
and would therefore be able to give away 1m to those people in most need. But
who are they?
What charities does Ord give to?
"Some people think that the most important thing is to help the people who are
the worst off. I think that's not always the case. What's really important is
to help people as well as you can and often the people the worst off are easier
to help, but not always.
"For example, someone in the UK suffering from severe depression has possibly a
worse life than people I help in Africa or South Asia but it turns out that
it's really difficult to help that person, but much easier to help the person
abroad.
"I'm not as focused on where people are, as how much I can help them. A lot of
people can switch off when they hear 'cost-effectiveness' but if you only have
a certain amount of money then the real question is how much you can do with
it."
Using the methodology of the World Health Organisation in calculating how much
a sum of money can "buy" in terms of extending the lives of those in need, he
says medical interventions in developing countries can be 10,000 times more
cost-effective than those in the UK. And he carefully researches which
charities he thinks make the most difference.
Toby Ord Giving away a third of your income doesn't preclude the odd luxury
The 10,000 he gave away last year he says equates to 4,000 extra years of life
at full health for people in those countries where those charities do their
work.
That's all very well and to be applauded but wouldn't it be, well, more
British, to do this quietly? Not if you want to encourage others to do the
same, says Ord.
"It's not that amazing. I'm not that impressed by this, but I'm glad that
people feel it's a good story. The median income is 18,000 so I'm not living
off anything less than the median person in the UK.
"It's quite possible to present this as a very positive thing. You can help
people so much without impacting on your own life. We can still live a
middle-class life on this kind of money."
He's aware of the arguments people have against giving to charities in the
developing world, such as corruption and overpopulation, and he sets out to
address them on a section of his website.
Echoing the philosophy of Bill Gates, who believes going public encourages
other people into acts of generosity, Ord set up Giving What We Can to share
ideas about "good" charities and inspire each other. The figure of a tenth
originates from the Christian tithes, a tradition that many people still follow
today.
Some of his members give more away than that, but Ord insists he never makes
those that don't feel guilty about it.
"There is a strong moral obligation to give some away but I wouldn't like to
say how much. We're not saying that if you don't join up you're a bad person.
Cannot play media.You do not have the correct version of the flash player.
Download the correct version
Toby Ord explains why he's giving away his money
"There used to be conflict between what I wanted and what I thought was right
and that was frustrating, but over time it was just what I thought was right."
He used to feel guilty seeing poverty on television but giving away part of his
wealth has liberated him, and he says it gives meaning to his life.
"I've made some simple material sacrifices but sufficiently small that I don't
really care about them. In terms of emotional comfort, you feel more satisfied
with what you're doing with your life."
The promise of a warm glow inside, no matter how many lives saved, may be a
hard sell at a time of such belt-tightening and cuts, but Ord responds that the
UK remains a very wealthy country, compared with many others.
And his own budget-trimming doesn't extend to Christmas spending. He did his
shopping early and posted the presents to relatives in Australia, which he
plans to visit next year.
A far greater gift awaits thousands of others.
Send us your comments using the form below
I don't want to belittle what is clearly a very significant and generous
gesture but this couple's combined income AFTER charity giving is significantly
more than my household income with three children to raise
Nick, Yorkshire
Fantastic! What an inspiring article...I manage to give about 10% but wish it
could be more (on a single, not-particularly-high-income it's not easy right
now, but I'm going to look at it in the new year) I hope more people follow Mr.
Ord's example - I have found giving, even when I have to badger myself into
doing it, to be so rewarding. Giving money away somehow makes what I'm left
with feel like riches; generosity begets gratitude.
Rachel, West Midlands
Interestingly, If they were to take the same amount of money and invest it
wisely, (shares, real-estate etc) I strongly suspect that once growth kicks in
they could give away far more total money over their lifetime, whilst also
building up a stock of assets that will provide for them into retirement. These
assets could then be given to chosen charities as a bequest when no longer
needed. I'm not criticising the sentiment or the action - just the method.
Mike, Bolton
All good and well, but what some charities need is your time. So if you have no
spare cash then give a couple of hours a week..... you may like it.
Shelly, Birmingham
Sad thing is when he is old and low on money because he has given his wealth
away then he will find that nobody is willing to help him. For sure he will
find that he has given away far too much. Giving what you can afford is one
thing but he is giving away far more than he can afford for sure.
Dai Jones, Swansea
Very generous on his part but it's not for me. I work long and hard for my
money and have two children to provide for. I have a retirement to plan for and
want to be in a position to enjoy it. I still do my bit for charity and I am
happy with that. I do note that his wife has a very well paid job and they have
no children to provide for. It's easier to be generous when not worrying about
shoes, school trips etc.
Dave Griffiths, Pershore, Worcs
A commendable act. While not for everybody, still an inspiration and an
encouragement to all to recognise how well off they are and how much they can
do to help other. Really disappointing to see people using having children as
an excuse for not giving to charity! For a start - having kids is your choice!
Secondly, Ord's point is that while you may feel poor you are doubtless, by
world standards, fairly well off. Lastly - how disappointing that the very fact
that you have children has not led you to want to a: set an example to them and
encourage them to help others through charitable giving, and b: feel more for
children who are perhaps not as lucky as your own.
Zoe, Devon
Great example of human kindness, if we had more of this in the world we would
experience the shift we all hope to see one day.
Ian, London
What an interesting cross section of comments here. So many opinions and
criticisms on such a beautiful act. While I understand that Mr. Ord's income is
on the higher side of middle class and his wife earns an even higher income,
that's not exactly the point. I think today's society (on both sides of the
Atlantic) tends to value frivolous wealth, celebrity, material status symbols,
etc. Mr. Ord isn't asking people to match his monthly donation. He's pointing
out that most of us do engage in some small level of luxury that is not
essential to a fulfilling life. Even if you can only spare $5 a week, put it in
a jar and at the end of the year you've got well over $200 to donate.
Carolyn, Rochester NY, US