-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- (c) Copyright 1992 Norman Doering Norman Doering 19O NW Hills Dr. Valparaiso, IN. 46383 A sample chapter, and an introduction to the writing of Norman Doering. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- HOPE IS THE BAIT Dangerous Game. Whoever allows room in himself again for religious feeling these days must also allow it to grow: he cannot do otherwise. Then his nature gradually changes: it favors that which is dependent on or near the religious element; the whole range of his judgement and feeling is befogged, overcast with religious shadows. Feeling cannot stand still: be on your guard! -- Friedrich Nietzsche, Human, All Too Human aphorism 121 My indoctrination started in earliest childhood, so long ago I cannot remember when I first heard the words 'God' or 'Jesus.' For those who haven't been indoctrinated there is simple curiosity, and there is also desire and hope, as well as fear, to attract new people to Christianity. It starts as an invitation to read the Bible, or with the witnessing of Christians who invite you to come and see for yourself. The prospective Christian wants to know what it is these witnessing Christians are about, and if they really know anything. How many of us haven't, at one time or another in our youth, explored those realms of mysticism and religion, if only to make sure there was no reality behind someone else's outrageous claims? Ask yourself what it is you felt. These religionists and mystics offer forms of hope and knowledge that cannot be had in any other way. Science and rationalism, by contrast, offer a very gloomy and pessimistic portrait of man's nature and fate. Bertrand Russell captured the essence of this pessimistic view in his essay, "A Free Man's Worship." The essay can be found in Russell's book "Why I Am Not a Christian." "... Man is the product of causes which had no prevision of the end they were achieving; that his origin, his growth, his hopes and fears, his loves and his beliefs, are but the outcome of accidental collocations of atoms; that no fire, no heroism, no intensity of thought and feeling, can preserve an individual life beyond the grave; that all the labors of the ages, all the devotion, all the inspiration, all the noonday brightness of human genius, are destined to extinction in the vast death of the solar system, and the whole temple of man's achievement must inevitably be buried beneath the debris of a universe in ruins..." It's a passage often quoted by Christian writers who wish to explain why they find atheism so unacceptable, and this let's us know what some Christians are really running away from. This is the possibility of despair we must embrace in order to be atheists and I couldn't do that without shedding a few tears for all the lost hopes. It's the only hell that Christian belief can save anyone from and in this, the hope market, there are a lot of competitors more vicious than ordinary Christianity is. However, such despair is just as presumptuous as the unreal hope embraced in the Christian faith. No man really knows what waits for us after we've finished our lives, but it's hard to scientifically or rationally support any speculation beyond simple non-existence. We can only hope and dream. The toxic hope offered by any kind of mysticism, be it Christian or New Age, is more than just the conquest of death, it's the desire for a supernatural realm beyond this comparatively dull and mundane reality. We all seem to have a profound yearning, a hope, for a magic method that will free us from realities that will not obey our wishes, from loneliness, from sorrow, from failure, from fears of the unknown, and from death itself, from our pain, and from our fragile human bodies that will rot in the earth after our dreaming souls have flown the coup. Because of our ego-centricity we cannot accept the idea of death easily. We want to be free of nature's seemingly cruel dictates. It has been called the transcendental temptation, the siren call of mysticism, an escape from reality, and the theological seduction. It is a supernatural promise and it will not be kept. Some Christians don't exactly know what kind of promise it is they have faith in, but they are sure it is better than rational despair. Yes, it would be nice if we could live forever in some paradise. It would be nice if there were a God watching over us and protecting us. But merely wanting and believing in these things is not enough to make them real. Hope and expectation is the bait that draws the seeker in, but the seeker is soon introduced to the fear of eternal damnation. What goes into the Bible reader's imagination, those highly emotional and secretly irrational processes within the subconscious, may just be objectively collected there at first as he tries to determine for himself what the truth is. The Bible reader tries to learn, but secretly wants to dream of a supernatural realm where his deepest desires might be fulfilled, and also where his darkest fears might come true. Fantasy may be a natural and healthy way to explore our desires and fears, and so discover their nature, and then develope realistic plans for getting what it is we desire and avoiding what we fear, but Christian fantasy is almost totally detached from any contact with reality. The desires and fears generated by the biblical texts are ambiguous, extreme, and unrealistic. The Bible, and especially New Testament, is bewildering, difficult, obscure, and confusing. The Bible creates an unhealthy uneasiness, it stimulates fear and hope with both subtle and direct threats and promises. The New Testament aims to turn the truth seeker inward and work on his subconscious mind. A seed is planted within the prospects subconscious. Any objective determination about the truth or falsity of Biblical claims is difficult for those who do not understand the psychology. The Christian finds that he is dependent on priestly authority in order to understand his faith. The material that goes in to the mind, Biblical stories, rituals, impressive church structures, the herd instinct, mass media support, and peer pressure can be analyzed and so tell us something about this psychology and how the final effect is produced, and even something of the purposes that lay behind its design. Supernatural fantasies are generated when the Bible reader speculates on the meaning of the text. And these fantasies are given implicit support by a media that tells us our politicians, presidents, generals, and celebrities are mostly Christian. A media that rarely contradicts the Christian assumptions of our culture. As the Bible reader reads of miracles, the promise of life everlasting, supernatural powers, angels, transcendent realms, and magical healings his desire and fantasy, his fears and hopes, will motivate, develop, and grow as he continues his studies. (One of the darkest aspects of religion's appeal to hope is its appeal to the desperate. To the terminally ill who seek to be healed.) Talk to any Christian and you'll find out that they've created a very personal vision, a private reality map that is uniquely their own. While different Christian groups with different labels, such as Pentecostal, Fundamentalist, Charismatic, or Evangelical will advocate different interpretations of this supernatural fantasy each individual creates his own particular vision out of the mix of possibilities. For some people, once the Biblical seed of unreal hope and uncertain fear has been sown, a process of desire, expectation, and imagination begins in the hidden workings of the unconscious mind, in a secret world of mystical ideas, a world of ignorance and enormous possibility. The Bible reader begins to develope a murky image of his supernatural expectations and he seeks to clarify that image with further study. Instead of having his murky ideas clarified he is instead drawn further and further in to the trap. In time those things merely imagined, but still either feared or desired, may become part of our potential believer's reality map. The ideas are no longer just possibilities and speculations he entertains in his mind but are now 'real' to him. But 'real' only in the sense that they are emotionally loaded concepts that influence his desire and aversion behavior. The believer can no longer imagine, comfortably, a world view without his faith, his illusions. The emotion attached to these religious ideas is stronger than the emotion attached to the concepts and ideas in a more rational mind. While I have little experience with it, there seems to be a drug like emotional kick of joyous expectation associated with this process. At least this is what many Christians seem to claim when they talk about being 'born again.' None of us use logic and reason alone to create our theories and reality maps, or even to solve problems. The ideas seem to just come to us, popping into our heads, or picked up out of books we've sought out, or welling up out of some dark and mysterious depth within our minds. Sometimes when this happens we want to scream 'Eureka!' because we have solved an important problem, as did Archimedes when he discovered a way to determine the purity of gold. We use logic later, to check the work and put it in presentable order after the new ideas and insights have been attained. This does not invalidate the use of reason and logic as tools for understanding our world because the insights and ideas must survive the checking and ordering process which makes them valid, at the very least, if not demonstratably true. A gestation process seems to be involved in genuine conversion. New insights, beliefs, concepts, and perspectives emerge days, weeks, perhaps even years after exposure to the information. The fuel for the Christian transformation is obviously those deep seated hopes and fears that biblical psychotechnology exploits. The computer programmer's jargon of "garbage in, garbage out" applies to the human mind as well. Cram your head full of scientific data about a problem that needs to be solved and you'll arrive at a technological solution to the problem. Cram your head full of Biblical mysticism and you'll find yourself with superstitious fears of damnation and a desperate quest for salvation. It's the checking and ordering process that is often not carried out when it comes to religion, or if it is, it's carried out improperly. In most cases, it's not even possible to carry out this checking process. Much of the information given to us by our trusted authority figures, our priests and politicians, goes unchecked, for checking is a hard and time consuming process. It's a lot harder to think for oneself than it is to just trust our culture's properly accredited experts, be they priests, politicians, or scientists. The Bible discourages this checking process and asks for faith, and that's one good clue to its false nature. Whether it's Christian belief or a New Age dream, it is all caused by the same hidden psychological rational; "if it feels good believe it." There may be a biological drive that accounts for our choice of hope over despair. George E. Vaillant, who heads a team of psychologists at Dartmouth's Medical School, (Omni mag, "Mental Muscle" May '92) has gathered data for over 4O years that suggests that men who have a bleak and cynical outlook on life suffer from more serious illnesses later. Our outlook on life could have a direct effect on our immune system's ability to fight off disease. The fantastic and extreme, but very unrealistic, hope offered by Christianity does feel good up to a point. All of us feel joy when we have great and hopeful expectations. However, we have to build up our hopes and goals here in the 'real' world, we have to base them on rational evidence. If a person can convince themselves that they are one of the saved, or the chosen, then the emotional effect produced would logically be one of joyous expectation. This joyous expectation feels good, it's one real motive for belief, but most Christians, it seems, only get that emotional kick once and it doesn't last. The price paid for these fantastic expectations, however, is the acceptance of some very fearful expectations should the believer's faith ever falter. At this point the true believer becomes emotionally committed to his religion. The disillusionment involved in giving up these unreal hopes would be extreme now. The believer has been locked in by the use of fear, by a kind of existential black mail, and the effects of dropping his faith are as painful as a drug addict quitting drugs. The longer he continues, the harder it is to quit. He knows his faith is real and powerful because he feels it. He knows what it feels like to be without it. A lot of different versions of Christianity have grown out of the long historical diversification and decomposition of the original Roman Catholic Church. Not even the Catholics are what they once were. However, at their root they all claim to base their faiths on the Bible. It is the 'interpretation' of that book that they all argue about, and it is their 'interpretation' of that book that they base their faith on. They all assume that there is at least honesty and wisdom there, if it's not claimed to be the revealed word of God. Liberal Christian leaders say many kind and sensible things in the public media, and they pretend that this is all that their religion is about. This is mostly Christian propaganda and it is all based on a few scarce passages in which men are instructed to love, and to love one another. This facade of being an institution dedicated to moral and ethical education, to good will, to hope, to social progress, to 'humanism,' and the biblical passages promising God's love is just a lure for the Christian trap. It is nothing but the bait in a bait and switch scam. Those who try to make Christianity into a mere institution for ethical and moral education are stuck with a Bible they can't allow themselves to interpret too accurately. A good example of this kind of liberal Christianity can be found in bishop John Shelby Spong's books. Spong's "Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism" is an attack on those Christians who take the Bible too literally, especially the televangelists and fundamentalists. Spong, a Christian bishop, says that the fundamentalists are too ignorant of science, 'modern' Biblical criticism, and 'correct' Biblical interpretation. Yet Spong still finds the Bible to be of value as a message of 'love,' and as a call to humanism. Spong is not able to make or find any kind of concrete interpretation of his message by use of the Bible, but can only tell us this 'love,' this 'religious impulse,' must be felt and language is ultimately inadequate for the task of expressing it. Christians are sure that whatever it is the Bible has to say it's important. (It is! But they're not going to like it.) What liberal and humanistic Christians don't realize is that they are the inheritors of a philosophy based on rebellion against, and questioning of, the Bible's original purposes. Martin Luther was the first to successfully challenge the Roman Catholic dominance, and its 'infallible' Pope, and create a new church. Ever since then Christianity has been in a slow state of decline. The kind, loving, philosophical, and modernist theology that has evolved out of this was designed to more effectively hide the original psychological poison, not to interpret the Bible correctly. All the kindly, humane, and sensible things that Christian leaders say, even when directly quoted from the Bible, are not what Christianity truly stands for. It is just the bait. It is this desire and hope that draws people, who haven't been indoctrinated from childhood, in. All religions use it. The liberal Christian's imagination and desire for a utopian world of Christian brotherhood and fellowship is only a half truth. It could never really exist, and what little tid bits of moral behavior, if any, Christianity has contributed to our culture are part of a very mixed blessing. Spreading 'God's word' will not spread any more tolerance and love than it already has. We've already seen the results. More psychological poison will be spread than love, for the Bible is psychological poison. This poison, whether it was created by Arrius Piso and his conspirators or not, was originally used to lure people into accepting slavery. Jesus asked us to have faith and take 'no thought' for tomorrow for our heavenly father knows our needs before we ask him. He thus lulls into a state of false security with his beautiful and hypnotic lies. Just feel the "peace which passeth all understanding" and relax, trust God and everything will turn out alright. Life will no longer be an anxious and uncertain struggle. Take no thought for politics and you'll be asked to go to war for someone else's gain. Take no thought for economic justice and you will become a slave. Refuse to take thought for tomorrow and God will let you starve. We've already seen the results of leaving these things to 'God' and the Church, it was called the Dark Ages. In Acts 4:32-37 the Christians are told to sell all they own, give the money to the church, and live together in what appears to be small communes, much like the Essenes did. A little later, in Acts 5:1-1O, Anani and his wife Sapphira lose their lives because they kept some money for themselves. Apparently these early Christians were expected to turn over everything to the trust of their church. What happened when they did this? This promise made to lazy minded believers, who were suppose to be of one mind, apparently backfired on the early church's leaders the first time they tried to use it. Many of those who entered into this kind of community, which sounds so much like a modern cult, must have been a problem for later the New Testament authors added, in 2 Thessalonians 3:1O, "If anyone will not work, let him not eat." Indeed, what kind of power could they have had over these people if they could starve them to get work out of them? I suggest you read these passages in context and see for yourself. The original biblical appeal to laziness of mind must have drawn in quite a few converts who were lazy about everything else too, or else they just weren't of one mind as Paul claimed, for they apparently had to starve them to get any work out of them. If they could be starved, then how free were people in these communities? Had they been lured into some kind of slavery? Work but don't think, for the cult leaders, will think for you, be an example unto you, and tell you exactly what God wants you to do. Today the church does not ask believers to sell all they own and give it to the church, only the most obviously dangerous cults do that now. Today the believer is more or less on his own, though in a mostly Christian world, and it is only suggested that he tithe 1O% of his income to the church. THE END ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The above essay, 'Hope is the Bait,' is intended, along with the other essay, 'Fear is the Trap,' to be part of a larger work tentatively titled 'The Dark Secrets of Religious Psychotechnology.' My goal is to study the psychological purposes and intentions of the Biblical authors in light of the theory presented by Abelard Reuchlin and John Duran that claims the New Testament is the work of Arrius Piso and his conspirators. This file is Dos ASCII text from PCwrite. You may consider these essays shareware. The shareware concept allows users to copy and distribute these files as long as the files are not altered. This file is 23373 bytes, if it's not, it has been altered. You may write to ask me about the file lengths and possible alterations of any shareware I've produced. These two essays may be re-printed free of charge if my name and address are included, if I am credited as the source of the article or excerpt, and if the fact that these essays are part of a larger work is mentioned. I intend to publish 'The Dark Secrets of Religious Psychotechnology,' first on computer disk. If the responce is good I will have a booklet printed up. You may ask about display, classified, and insert advertising on the disk or booklet. I have no policy or rates in mind, first I must what kind of interest there may be. I would like help out other interested parties and give my readers more sources for information. If you would like to order in advance of my completion of the work then please use the order form below. �������������������������������������������������������������������������������� Advance Order Form THE DARK SECRETS OF RELIGIOUS PSYCHOTECHNOLOGY $7.5O (Norm's booklet on disk) [] YES!! Please send me 'THE DARK SECRETS OF RELIGIOUS PSYCHOTECHNOLOGY' on computer disk. Enclose is my check or money order for $7.5O. Price and availability is NOT subject to change without notice during the '92 to '93 period. Price includes whatever shipping and handling expenses I incur. Allow 30 days after target date (March 1, 1993), or after you order, for delivery. If I cannot deliever a computer disk with promised material I will return your money in full. Only 5.25" DSDD floppy disks are available at this time. Fill out the form below and include check or money order with your request. No returns except for physical damage. No credit. All donations final. Name____________________________________________________________________________ Address_________________________________________________________________________ City___________________________________________State_____________Zip____________ Send to: NORMAN DOERING 19O N.W. HILLS DR. VALPARAISO, IN. 46383-5375 �������������������������������������������������������������������������������� X-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-X Another file downloaded from: NIRVANAnet(tm) & the Temple of the Screaming Electron Jeff Hunter 510-935-5845 The Salted Slug Strange 408-454-9368 Burn This Flag Zardoz 408-363-9766 realitycheck Poindexter Fortran 510-527-1662 Lies Unlimited Mick Freen 415-583-4102 Tomorrow's 0rder of Magnitude Finger_Man 415-961-9315 My Dog Bit Jesus Suzanne D'Fault 510-658-8078 New Dork Sublime Demented Pimiento 415-566-0126 Specializing in conversations, obscure information, high explosives, arcane knowledge, political extremism, diverse sexuality, insane speculation, and wild rumours. ALL-TEXT BBS SYSTEMS. Full access for first-time callers. We don't want to know who you are, where you live, or what your phone number is. We are not Big Brother. "Raw Data for Raw Nerves" X-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-X