Facebook duo's fight with founder

By Rory Cellan-Jones

Technology Correspondent, BBC News

The two Americans who were awarded millions of dollars after claiming they had

come up with the idea for Facebook say their legal battle isn't over.

Cameron and Tyler Winkelvoss studied at Harvard University alongside Facebook

founder Mark Zuckerberg, where they started a site called ConnectU.

In 2008 a protracted legal battle between the two sides ended with the payment

of an undisclosed sum.

Facebook said that that it now considers "the matter concluded".

The Winkelvoss twins spoke to the BBC on the eve of the Boat Race, in which

they will both row for Oxford.

Cameron Winkelvoss refused to confirm the extent of the 2008 settlement -

thought to be $65m - but said: "I think it is safe to say the chapter is not

closed on the matter."

Social network shock

His brother Tyler said: "It's our duty to stand for principles. We're willing

to wait around and make sure that's what right has been made right."

It was a scary encounter in an unlikely setting for a technology

correspondent. In the very grand 16th-Century hall of Christ Church College

Oxford I was sitting with two giant American rowers, and wondering when to

broach the subject of Facebook

Rory Cellan-Jones BBC's technology correspondent

The two brothers started work on ConnectU in 2003. They thought that computer

science student Mark Zuckerberg was working with them, until he launched a

similar site called thefacebook.com.

Mr Zuckerberg's site became hugely popular on the Harvard campus and then,

under the name Facebook, turned into a global success.

"It was really just a sense of shock, " said Tyler Winkelvoss. "It turned into

how can we right this wrong."

The settlement of the battle between Facebook and ConnectU involved the award

of Facebook shares to the Winkelvoss twins.

The continuing dispute appears to centre on the value of those shares in a

company which has not been publicly floated.

In a statement about the dispute Facebook told the BBC:

"The settlement has been enforced by the courts and attempts to delay that

decision have been denied twice.

"We hope that discussion of spurious and false allegations and other matters

that were concluded years ago are not distracting anyone from their

preparations for the race. We consider the matter concluded."

The brothers also revealed that after years of avoiding the social network they

themselves have joined Facebook.

"We weren't on it for a long period of time," said Cameron Winkelvoss. "But

it's a utility and we're deserving to take part in that. It's a great way to

keep in touch with people back home."

Story from BBC NEWS:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/technology/8596715.stm

Published: 2010/04/01 07:42:25 GMT