đŸ Archived View for nnix.com âș ulysses âș index.gmi captured on 2024-08-18 at 17:22:13. Gemini links have been rewritten to link to archived content
âŹ ïž Previous capture (2022-04-28)
-=-=-=-=-=-=-
. .|
| || , .,---.,---.,---.,---.
| || | |`---.`---.|---'`---.
`---'`---'`---|`---'`---'`---'`---'
`---'
Ulysses is an encyclopedic epic which tracks three Dubliners' intersecting lives on June 16 1904. Joyce was not aiming to shock or impress the reader, nor was his work meant to be pretentious: it is a modernist literary experiment intended to depict a cross-section of everyday life in a wealth of analytic detail which Joyce called "vivisective".
Main themes:
Ulysses can't be read, only re-read.
There are innumerable publications and reviews of Ulysses. Two exceptionally negative ones are presented here. There are far more reasons to read Ulysses than to ignore Ulysses - and so we'll let the opposition make their case. It's worth noting that the distillation of modernist literature represented by Ulysses was difficult to interpret in its time, as it represented a break from both traditional use of language and traditional storytelling.
In my opinion, if you want beautiful "standard" English, read Nabokov's Lolita. If you want a traditional story, there's always Moby Dick. Joyce was aiming to accomplish neither with Ulysses, so the Bersani review below is presented as a more modern assessment, with that context fully understood.
Against Ulysses, Leo Bersani (from Casebook)
(The book is a ruse.)
We have only to glance at the title and read page one of Ulysses to be forewarned: trickery, cunning and ruse are the novel's first connotations, and the possibility is thus raised from the very start that those qualities not only belong to certain characters within the novel but, much more significantly, that they define an authorial strategy. Approaching it with naivete is tantamount to walking into a trap. - Bersani, 202
(The book is only a character study if read superficially.)
We should begin by doing justice to the interpretive gains to be had from the naive assumption that Ulysses can be read as if it were a nineteenth-century realistic novel. If we were unaware of the avant-gardist claims made for Joyce's novel, we would have little hesitation in speaking of it as a psychological work, as a novel of character. - Bersani, 203
(The book recruits readers to the cause of modernism, and is now outdated.)
Is there no relation between elaborate analyses of Ulysses as pure linguistic effects and a type of psychological and moral appreciation already made obsolete by the New Criticism of half a century ago? My point is... that the relation is only too clear, and that Joyce's avant-gardism largely consists in his forcing the readers to complete the rearguard action which the novel itself simultaneously performs and elaborately disguises. - Bersani 205-206
The effect of the New Criticism was to decontextualize literature, to isolate it outside the social fabric and ignore its political import. Its practitioners were as compulsive in their attention to form as in their disregard of a writer's political views. They viewed a writer's responsibility to be entirely to his conscience and to his craft. - Segall, Joyce in America, 120
(And yet, the book is singularly compelling.)
The community of Ulysses and its exegetes is redemptive in its failure to acknowledge any operative relation between experience - of this text or of reality - and the forms of intelligibility which it proposes. It is the Vita Nuova in which Joyce thrillingly proposes we spend our life with him. The call is very hard not to heed. Even in writing "against Ulysses," we can only feel a great sadness in leaving it; to stop working on Ulysses is like a fall from grace. - Bersani, 228
Strange Necessity, Rebecca West
(Joyce is playing with the reader's emotions, and it isn't durable.)
To condition the expression of one's experience out of regard for the effect on one's audience's mind is to bring into the artistic process a factor so little of a constant, since that mind is perpetually changing according to the social and intellectual movements of the time, and one's understanding of it is as unstable. - West, 6-7
(Joyce is a narcissist, and writes to please the reader rather than to represent reality.)
There is working here a narcissism, a compulsion to make self-image and to make it with an eye to the approval of others, which turns Stephen Dedalus into a figure oddly familiar for a protagonist of a book supposed to be revolutionary and unique. - West, 11
Ulysses is written by a genius, but there is in [it a] narcissistic inspiration, which inevitably deforms all its products with sentimentality, since the self-image which it is the aim of narcissism to create is made not out of material that has been imaginatively experienced but out of material that has been selected as likely to please others. - West, 12
(The Odyssey connection doesn't work.)
[the connection] plunges Mr. Joyce's devotees into profound ecstasies from which they never recover sufficiently to ask what the devil is the purpose that is served by these analogies. - West, 18
(Nobody thinks or talks like this.)
Incoherence, that is to say the presentation of words in other than the order appointed by any logic of words not in sentence formation, is at least a real device and not just a condition, and while it is also suitable for the handling only of a special case, that special case is certainly contained in Ulysses. But unfortunately, Mr. Joyce applies it to many things in Ulysses as well as that special case. To begin with, he writes down these strings of words as if they corresponded to the stream of one's consciousness; as if, should one resolve to describe one's impressions as they came, one would produce isolated words and phrases which would not cohere into sentences. - West, 23
(But you might want to read it anyway.)
In any event I have got to live in a world where a large number of people are to varying degrees conditioned by a knowledge of Ulysses. I shall not be able to analyze any experience of mine in which they take part unless I can fully comprehend their conditioning in this respect. - West, 37
"Walking Into Eternity" Dublin Tour (Part 1)
"Walking Into Eternity" Dublin Tour (Part 2)
The Evening Telegraph (Context)
The Evening Telegraph 16 June 1904 (Full Reconstruction)
Ulysses Annotated, the best single annotated companion for the Ulysses reader.
Gilbert's Ulysses (a study), less well organized than Ulysses Annotated, but still valuable insight.
Ulysses, Order, and Myth (T.S. Eliot)
"La ci darem la mano" in Ulysses
Joyce Tools, tons of maps and tables
Full-Text Ulysses, with Hypertext Annotations
A codename generator using only words from Ulysses
| |
,---.|---.,---.,---.|--- ,---.,---.,---.
| | |,---|| || |---'| `---.
`---'` '`---^|---'`---'`---'` `---'
|
"Dispossessed son in contest"
8:00 a.m., at the Martello tower at Sandycove (on the shore of Dublin Bay, seven miles southeast of the center of Dublin).
Read "The Odyssey" Books 1-4
Modernism Lab article on Telemachus
Mourning and Melancholia, Sigmund Freud
Stephen Dedalus, in part a self-portrait of the author, has just returned to Ireland from his studies in Paris (to which he was headed at the end of Joyceâs preceding work, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man). He shares lodgings with a medical student, Buck Mulligan, in the Martello tower at Sandycove, and the book opens with a rooftop exchange between Stephen and the irreverent Mulligan. Stephen has been kept awake by the nighttime ravings of Mulliganâs friend Haines, an Englishman with bad dreams, and wants to know when the latter is leaving. He also complains to Mulligan about his (Mulliganâs) distasteful comment on the recent death of Stephenâs mother. The two then go downstairs for breakfast with Haines. They leave the tower together for the swimming hole, where Mulligan, like a good usurper, asks the work-bound Stephen for his key and some money and sets a date for them to meet at half-past noon (to spend more of the latterâs earnings). (Smith)
"The wisdom of the ancients"
10:00 a.m., at Mr. Deasyâs school for Protestant boys in the Dublin suburb of Dalkey.
Read "The Odyssey" Books 1-4
Modernism Lab article on Nestor
We ïŹnd Stephen at work attempting, with little optimism or success, to teach a history class. As the apathetic and unruly bunch quickly disperses for hockey, a lone lingerer named Sargent makes his cautious way to the teacherâs desk for help with his arithmetic, and Stephen sees in the boy a pathetic portrait of his own youth. Then Stephen suffers his turn as pupil, receiving along with his salary a tedious lecture from the pompous Mr. Deasy, who then enlists Stephenâs help in getting a tedious letter of his published in the press. (Smith)
"Primal matter"
11:00 a.m., at Sandymount Strand (the beach near the mouth of the river Liffey).
Read "The Odyssey" Books 5-8
Modernism Lab article on Proteus
Stephen wanders the beach, thinking of his past, his family (especially his dead mother), and the constant change and uncertainty of life. He knows he is seeking something, something that cannot be found in family life, in intellectual pursuits, but he still does not know what that something is. Stephen realizes the difïŹculty of connecting with other people, but also senses that he is part of the cycle of life and death. He sees this in the movement of the ocean and his own urination, and as he moves off down the beach, thinking of drowned men, we are ready for the next part of the book. (Smith)
"The departing wayfarer"
8:00 a.m., at Leopold and Molly Bloomâs house at 7 Eccles Street, Dublin.
Read "The Odyssey" Books 9-10
Modernism Lab article on Calypso
We ïŹnally meet Odysseus himself in his modern manifestation as Leopold Bloom, an endearing unheroic 38-year-old Dublin-born Jew of Hungarian ancestry who canvasses newspaper advertisements for a living. We see him ïŹrst at home and follow him on his domestic morning chores, buying himself a kidney at the butcherâs, delivering to his wife Molly a breakfast in bed with the morning mail (including, he notices, a note from her impresario Blazes Boylan, with whom she will have a romantic rendezvous at the house later in the day). Back down in the kitchen he reads a letter from their daughter Milly, then visits the outhouse in great detail before ïŹnally embarking upon his long-dayâs wandering through the city on business, pleasure, respectful attendance at Dignamâs funeral, and the pursuit of not being at home when his wifeâs lover calls. (Smith)
"The temptation of faith"
10:00 a.m., at various spots including Sir John Rogersonâs Quay, Westland Row post ofïŹce, and Leinster Street baths.
Read "The Odyssey" Books 9-10
Modernism Lab article on Lotus-Eaters
Bloom visits the post ofïŹce under his pseudonym Henry Flower to pick up a letter from his sentimentally amorous pen pal âMartha Clifford.â On his way to read the letter he bumps into the tiresome McCoy, whose conversation he suffers long enough to indulge himself in a pleasant voyeuristic distraction concerning an attractive woman boarding a carriage across from them. McCoy notices Bloomâs mourning attire and learns of Paddy Dignamâs funeral, asking Bloom to put his name down as having attended. McCoy out of the way, Bloom reads the letter, then allows himself a few minutesâ repose in All Hallows church where, watching the service, he muses upon religion to humorous ironic effect. On his way out Bloom decides to make use of the little time left before the funeral to get Mollyâs lotion from the chemist. He buys a bar of soap for himself and walks towards the baths. He is interrupted by Lyons, who asks to see Bloomâs newspaper to look up a horse running that day. Lyons mistakes Bloomâs offer to give him the paperâ âI was going to throw it awayââas a tip on the âdark horseâ Throwaway. (Smith)
"The descent into nothingness"
11:00 a.m., at Prospect Cemetery in Glasnevin, north of Dublin.
Read "The Odyssey" Book 11
Bloomâs odyssey through Dublin continues now by carriage (accompanied by Cunningham, Power and Stephenâs father Simon Dedalus) to the cemetery to attend Dignamâs funeral. Hynes the reporter buttonholes Bloom about the identity of a mystery man wearing a Mackintosh coat. Death is everywhere in this episode, explored from various perspectives via Bloomâs rambling, often fumbling ruminations on the nuts and bolts of spiritual beliefs and rites, and of decomposition and renewal. (Smith)
"The derision of victory"
12:00 noon, at the newspaper ofïŹces of the Freemanâs Journal (and the Evening Telegraph), the vicinity of the General Post OfïŹce, and Nelsonâs Pillar.
Review "The Odyssey" Book 10
Modernism Lab article on Aeolus
In this humorous study of hot air, we discover Bloom pursuing a few minutes of actual work as he visits the newspaper to negotiate an ad for a client (the grocer Keyes). The editorâs ofïŹce is bustling with the confabulation among a changing consortium of hangers-on discussing the history of oration, rhetoric and journalism. Simon Dedalus leaves and is replaced by Stephen (with Deasyâs letter), who recites his âParable of the Plums.â Crawford, impatient for a drink, waves Bloom off, describing to him the precise location of his royal Irish anatomy the latterâs client Keyes may kiss. (Smith)
"Despondency"
1:00 p.m., at Davy Byrneâs Pub and the National Museum.
Modernism Lab article on Lestrygonians
The subject of food and eating is explored here with the detailed attention afforded death and decomposition two episodes ago. We follow Bloom through a panoply of lunchtime noises and smells and their associations in search of an aesthetically satisfying bite. Along the way, he bumps into Josie Breen, who updates him on the unpleasant status of her own life with her lunatic husband. Bloom also learns from her about Mina Purefoy, whoâs been in the maternity hospital three days already, and demonstrates his characteristic empathy. Feeling relaxed and satisïŹed from a cheese sandwich and glass of burgundy at Davy Byrneâs, he takes a walk, helps a blind man cross the street, and ducks into the National Museum (to avoid bumping into his wifeâs prospective lover). (Smith)
"The double-edge sword"
2:00 p.m., at the National Library.
Read "The Odyssey" Book 12
Modernism Lab article on Scylla & Charybdis
Meanwhile, not far from Bloom, we ïŹnd Stephen at the National Library, hard at work selling his Hamlet theory to another hardworking group of literati. Shakespeare, it is suggested, was father not merely of his own children but of his own grandfather, a ghostly father of all his race. Stephen sees Shakespeareâs work, pervaded as it is by the themes of usurpation, adultery and exile, as an art born from the anguish of impotence. The quasi-Socratic dialogue, pitting Aristotle (Stephen) against his teacher Plato (the mystic A. E. Russell), is interrupted by the spirited arrival of the profane Mulligan, who has just come through the Museum, where he noticed Bloom. (Smith)
"The hostile milieu"
3:00 p.m., along the streets of Dublin.
Modernism Lab article on The Wandering Rocks
Blog posts on The Wandering Rocks
This episode comprises nineteen separate passages, each a short poetic sketch of a scene or event happening somewhere in Dublin. Some of these episodes, though seemingly unrelated, appear to be happening simultaneously, affording the reader the sense of a wide-angle lens through which the whole city may be viewed. This uniïŹcation of disparate elements is effected the more tellingly by the culminating scene, wherein a viceregal procession is depicted as observed by many of the characters individually portrayed. (Smith)
"The sweet deceit"
About 4:00 p.m., at The Concert Room (saloon at the Ormond Hotel).
Modernism Lab article on Sirens
Musical logic dictates the structure, sense and exhilaration of this episode, which begins with an overture (composed, as in traditional opera, from themes, motifs, and highlights of the action to come) and proceeds through a fugal handling of voices, ideas, taps of a blind manâs cane, and nostalgic wisps of sentimental song. We follow Bloom into the Ormond Bar where he witnesses Boylan ïŹirting with the Sirens (the seductive barmaids Miss Douce and Miss Kennedy) before departing for his conquest of our heroâs wife. Bloomâs impotence to intervene and prevent his cuckoldry, together with his fascination with his adversary, skillfully maintains a subtle but pervasive tension and a haunting poignance. (Smith)
"Egocidal terror"
5:00 p.m., at Barney Kiernanâs pub.
Review "The Odyssey" Book 9
odernism Lab article on Cyclops
One of the funniest chapters of a supremely funny book, âCyclopsâ maintains its ironic humor with the help of a thoroughly unreliable narratorâa bitter, petty barïŹy equipped with a sardonic outlook and an exquisite sense for the clichĂ©. The âIâ narratorâs account is interrupted by the voice of another narratorâone countering âIââs vigorous deïŹations with equally preposterous inïŹations (in the form of amusing descriptions of Rabelaisian proportions). Among those so described is âthe citizen,â a worn-out patriotic bigot in an eyepatch who plays Polyphemus to Bloomâs Odysseus. Jewish Bloom ïŹnds himself in unwelcome territory in this drunken den of nationalist bigotry. Distracted over the scene he imagines (correctly) to be transpiring at his home, Bloom allows himself to be drawn into an argument with the anti-Semitic âcitizen.â Even Bloomâs very presence in the pub is misunderstood. He has come to meet Cunningham so that the two of them can visit Dignamâs widow with an offer of help; yet he is perceived as having come only to collect his winnings on Throwaway. Finally, when Bloom fails to pick up a round of drinks, the atmosphere of suspicion about him ignites into a confrontation over nationalism and intolerance given in comically cosmic dimensions, and our hero is whisked away from catastrophe by Cunningham âlike a shot off a shovel.â (Smith)
"The projected mirage"
8:00 p.m., at the rocks on Sandymount Strand.
Review "The Odyssey" Book 5
Modernism Lab article on Nausicaa
We return to the beach that served as stage for Stephenâs earlier musings and ïŹnds Bloom there pondering his perception (markedly less theoretical) of young Gerty MacDowell and her underwear. Even less concerned with philosophy is Gerty, who gleans she is the object of [a] manâs desire and happens to be quite busy living up to her objectiïŹcation. When her group runs off in pursuit of the nearby ïŹreworks display, she stays behind, soaking up the male gaze and feeding it with more and more view of leg until the exploding Roman candles overhead mimic Bloomâs ejaculation. Meanwhile, anthem-like strains of organ and menâs voices are heard emanating from a nearby church to remind us there is a temperance retreat in progress. When Gerty gets up from the rock and lamely limps away, we are left with Bloom alone on the dim-lit beach in a guilt-tainted postmasturbatory reverie, reïŹecting on women and sexuality with his characteristic concreteness, providing a complementary foil to Gertyâs ruminations on the subject. (Smith)
"The eternal herds"
10:00 p.m., at the National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street.
Review "The Odyssey" Book 10
Modernism Lab article on Oxen of the Sun
Bloom continues his circuitous avoidance of home, hearth and Blazes Boylan by paying a call on Mina Purefoy, whom he knows to be experiencing a difïŹcult birth. At the hospital he runs into a group of young carousers including Stephen, who happens to be avoiding his homecoming as well on account of his own problem with usurpers. Bloom once again ïŹnds himself to be an outsider looking in on an unwelcoming society. His concern for the well-being of his surrogate (spiritual) son, Stephen, prompts him to linger on well past the delivery of the baby until the doctor is free to leave with the gang for the nearest pub. The language in which the episode lives creates a masterful portrait of the English language itself, evolving as it does from the highly convoluted and ponderous Latinate and Saxon stages through the various centuries of signature literary styles to the jargon-riddled commercial babble of modernity, perhaps the worse for wear with the help of an escalating rate of intoxication. (Smith)
"The man-hating ogress"
12:00 midnight, at Bella Cohenâs Brothel, Tyrone Street (in the red-light district Joyce called ânighttownâ).
Review "The Odyssey" Book 10
Read "The Odyssey" Books 13-16
Modernism Lab article on Circe
In keeping with the late hour, high blood alcohol level, and magical powers of Homerâs Circe, this episode is expressed largely in a hallucinatory manner that invites comparison with the metaphoric power of dream logic. Bloom and Stephen move freely in and out of a sorceressâ world, where personages and fears from their recent and distant pasts are made manifest to them in a seamless process of metamorphosis, and put down on the page in dramatic form, replete with stage directions. Stephen heads for the red-light district and is followed by Bloom, who is concerned in a fatherly way over Stephenâs well-being. In the house of Bella Cohen, Bloom ïŹirts with Zoe, falls under the spell of the whoremistress Bella, and keeps watch over Stephen, who, after a traumatic hallucinatory visit from his deceased mother, attempts to break her hold on his psyche by smashing his walking stick against Bellaâs chandelier. Bloom pays Bella for the damage and follows Stephen into the street. Stephen is punched by a British solder unimpressed by Stephenâs rhetorical skills, and Bloom protects the unconscious recipient of that punch so that the latter might avoid falling into the custody of the police. The episode (and with it Part II, the âOdysseyâ proper) ends poignantly with Bloomâs vision of his own son Rudy (who had died eleven years ago at the age of eleven days) as he might have been in life, now eleven. By associating Rudy with Stephen at this point, the image powerfully reinforces the bookâs undercurrent theme of father and son in search of each other. (Smith)
"The ambush on home ground"
1:00 a.m., at the cabmanâs coffeehouse shelter beneath the Loop Line bridge.
Read "The Odyssey" Books 17-20
Modernism Lab article on Eumaeus
Bloom escorts the revived Stephen to a nearby cabmanâs shelter in hopes of sobering the young man up and bringing him home to Eccles Street for a good nightâs sleep. The shelter is run by a reputed ex-Invincible known as âSkin-the-Goat,â whose clientele are being entertained by the tattoos and tall tales of a sailor named Murphy, just back with a fresh batch of rare exploits on the ship Stephen watched that morning from the strand. Bloomâs best efforts at communication with his newfound spiritual son are met with certain disappointments, beautifully emphasized by the episodeâs narrative technique, a prose style so hopelessly laden with subordinate clauses, derelict predicates, tireless wandering constructions, and delicious clichĂ©s that the reader yearns for bedtime more keenly than do the protagonists. Nevertheless, our hero is triumphant in his mission, and eventually leads the young bard through the vicissitudes of city life and tired language to safe harbor at Eccles Street. (Smith)
"Armed hope"
2:00 a.m., at Bloomâs house.
Read "The Odyssey" Books 21-24
Modernism Lab article on Ithaca
Bloom remembers he had forgotten to remember to take his key. Through the birdâs-eye vantage afforded by a loftily impersonal third-person narrative, we watch Bloom climb over the railing and into the house to receive Stephen for a friendly cup of cocoa and conversation, a refused offer to stay the night, and a cordial parting urination together beneath the stars. After Stephen leaves, Bloom ïŹnds his way to bed past rearranged furniture, remembrances of his past life with his adulterous wife, and crumbs from the jar of potted meat brought that afternoon by the usurper of his conjugal bed. Brushing away his predecessorâs crumbs, the returning hero climbs into bed, head to his wifeâs feet, boldly orders himself an unprecedented breakfast in bed (as we learn in the next chapter), metaphorically vanquishes an imagined host of her suitors, and then plants a kiss on her plump behind before his embarkation for the Kingdom of Hypnos down into a tiny blot of unconsciousness in the space of a dot on the page. (Smith)
"The past sleeps"
Infinite, or at least indefinite, at Bloom's House.
Modernism Lab article on Penelope
The world is Mollyâs now; rather, Molly is the world now, and through the massive, evershifting sea of liquid prose that constitutes her monologue, we explore the yet-unseen sides of things limned throughout the book from other, largely male, perspectives. Washing up on shore from this freely-ïŹowing tide of words (eight unpunctuated sentences totaling some nearly sixteen-hundred lines) are countless gems of insight into the psyche of Molly, Woman, and the world. Beginning with her surprise over Bloomâs breakfast order and some random remembrances of life with her husband, she proceeds in reverie over her recent tryst, before seeing it in the context of her past and future life. Mollyâs review of her marriage and family, and before that her childhood on Gibraltar, gives way by turns to amusing ambivalent appraisals of men and women, as well as ïŹights of romantic curiosity about younger men, like Stephen, before building to a great peroration of sustained lyrical sweep in afïŹrmation of the pervasive power of love, of the reality of loss, and, yes, of her ultimate acceptance of the man she married (or at least the man he was when she married him). Yes. (Smith)
The concluding pages, a passage of vivid lyrical beauty, are at once intensely personal and symbolic of the divine love of nature for her children, a springsong of the Earth; it is significant for those who see in Joyce's philosophy nothing beyond a blank pessimism, an evangel of denial, that Ulysses ends on a triple paean of affirmation. - Gilbert, 403