đŸ Archived View for gemini.ctrl-c.club âș ~ssb22 âș android.gmi captured on 2024-03-21 at 15:25:58. Gemini links have been rewritten to link to archived content
View Raw
More Information
âŹ
ïž Previous capture (2023-09-28)
âĄïž Next capture (2024-05-26)
đ§ View Differences
-=-=-=-=-=-=-
How to just about survive in Android OS
If purchasing hardware, beware of âShanzhaiâ models: these typically break down after 3 to 4 months, and some reportedly shipped with malware (e.g. Tecno).âReputable manufacturersâ devices should last several years, although some âbudgetâ options have been known to last less than two.âDevices advertised as âwaterproofâ are not necessarily *usable* in wet weather, and can have overly-sensitive touchscreens even in dry weather.âNewer devices tend to charge via USB-C; some devices using the older Micro-USB also have optional âmagnetic charge cablesâ to connect to their docking ports, which I suppose might increase the life of the device if the Micro-USB port breaks first.
Regarding BlackBerry devices, I believe the situation is:
Before Blackberry 10 - No Android support
Blackberry 10 (Q10, Passport etc) not upgraded to 10.2 - Simple, non-NDK applications can be repackaged for BlackBerry
10.2.1 - APKs install direct to phone; NDK works; most APIs supported, except for things like taking over the home screen or running a background sound recorder when app is not visible
Priv - *is* Android (in a security-enhanced fork)
but I havenât actually tested any BlackBerry device; in particular,
- I donât know if their physical keyboards are large enough to justify their higher prices,
- and I donât know to what extent the 2022 shutdown of their OTA provisioning service has affected the reliability of calling etc on Blackberry 10.
Some pre-4.4 devices, such as the Galaxy S2, are advertised as having 16G capacity, but only 2G of this is âdevice memoryâ and the rest appears as a fake âUSB diskâ which not all applications can use for their data.
- The âApplication Managerâ can be told to move some applications to the âSD cardâ (actually the fake USB disk), and may be able to move more applications if you first connect a cable and do adb -d shell pm set-install-location 2, but moving an application does not usually result in all its *data* being movedâmany applications still keep a lot of data on the more limited âdevice memoryâ even when the *code* is elsewhere.
- On the Galaxy S2, some âdevice memoryâ can also be freed by dialling *#9900# for SysDump and selecting âDelete dumpstate/logcatâ (repeat every few months).
- Some of these devices can be repartitioned to turn part of the âUSB diskâ into âdevice memoryâ (using, for example, a GNU/Linux box running Heimdall and an appropriate PIT file for the Galaxy), but youâd then need to re-flash the operating system from a download: many are of questionable legitimacy, and it also risks a USB glitch âbrickingâ the device, so I cannot recommend this procedure.
Newer devices are less likely to come with such inconvenient partitions in their memory.
Real MicroSD cards (usually SDHC i.e. up to 32GB) are supported by some (not all) devices, and can be used for storage of media but not all applications before Android 6 (which can âadoptâ a card for extra âinternalâ storage instead), but any new card must be tested with f3write and f3read (or equivalent) before use, since counterfeit high-capacity cards are common (e.g. â32Gâ where only 7.4GiB work reliably, even if the seller describes it as âgenuineâ or âauthorizedâ).âMany counterfeit sellers, when faced with a test report mentioning h2testw (a proprietary Windows equivalent of F3) issue a refund and tell you to keep the card.âSuch cards are often usable if repartitioned downwards to their true (smaller) capacity
- on GNU/Linux the easiest way to do this is probably to install gparted;
- on a Mac:
1. in the Terminal, check with mount to see which disk number it has,
2. unmount it with diskutil umount
3. use (e.g.) fdisk -e /dev/disk1 (ignore any âcould not open MBR fileâ errors)
4. edit 1 and set true size in 512-byte blocks
5. w and qâDisk Utility will likely pop up (launch it yourself if it doesnât)
6. select the first partition e.g. disk1s1 (*not* the partition table itself!) and erase.
- Usual disclaimers apply of course: mistakes with partitioning can erase your hard disk; if in doubt, leave it to an expert.
but repartitioned cards probably *shouldnât* be used for Android 6+ internal storage until somebody checks that setup honours the altered partition table.
If you donât have time for all this testing, complaining, repartitioning, and repeating until you get a high enough capacity, itâs well worth paying the extra few pounds to buy from a reputable high-street chain instead of online (but test it anyway, just in case they too get caught out).
You might also want to find an A1 or A2 logo to check the card is fast during random (not just sequential) access, depending on how you plan to use it.
Android 4 has a âFont sizeâ setting under âDisplayâ (although the range is limited); Android 6+ has âAccessibilityâ settings including Font size and also âDisplay sizeâ which changes the reported DPIâthis can work better with some applications.âAlso available is the âTalkBackâ screen reader, and a built-in screen magnifierâalthough a bug introduced in Android 13 can make its scrolling lag by dozens of seconds and sometimes lock so the phone needs soft-resetting.
Taming the Home screen
Some devices ship with âwidgetâ software that plays a continuous stream of advertisements from the Home screen, consuming your data allowance and generally being a distractionâespecially if you intend to use your device to demonstrate things to others.âSonyâs âWhatâs Newâ is one such example and cannot be disabled from Settings/Apps.âI was initially able to mitigate this by using Sonyâs âSimple Homeâ (which can give larger print, although the customisation options for Version 1.0 on Android 4.x donât allow for removal of its three âspeed dialâ slotsâI suggested moving these to the top i.e. furthest from your hands if you donât make voice calls from this device), and I suggested refusing to accept OS updates (such as from 4.4 to 5.0) just in case the update removes Simple Home and brings back the âWhatâs Newâ widget (Android security is basically a lost battle anywayâeven Googleâs own âNexusâ models have ceased to be patched just 3 years after initial releaseâso you should be aware that anything you store is at risk of compromise no matter what; if the consequences of that are worse than inconvenience, keep it on something thatâs more secure than Android)âbut it turns out thereâs a way to turn off pre-installed widgets without relying on the availability of Simple Home.âThe instructions that should have been in the box are as follows:
- Unwanted widgets etc can be long-pressed and then dragged to a dustbin which appears (except on the âAmazon Fireâ version of Android, where you may be stuck with them but you can at least change the order or drop them on top of each other to hide them in folders);
- on Android 4.x and 11.x a âpinchâ gesture can be used to remove empty âpanesâ (pages) if youâd rather have just a single page (automatic on 5â10)
- If the device will be used by a beginner whoâs unfamiliar with the difference between short and long presses, I suggest not placing tappable icons anywhere near where the dustbin or âcreate folderâ functions appear when they are long pressed;
- The print size *might* be increaseable in Settings but not by much; doing so will likely reset the layout to default; Simple Home (if available) might be preferable.
Useful applications
Unless otherwise specified, these can be searched for in the âPlay Storeâ, but beware that advertisers can pay for other apps to be listed at the top of the search results, so the app you searched for is not always the first result.
- Hackerâs Keyboard: The only application I could find with a correctly laid out on-screen Dvorak keyboard, although itâs still not as good as a physical keyboard (which is sorely lacking from most Android devices).âHackerâs Keyboard is Apache-licensed.
- QKSMS by Moez Bhatti (Android 5+): If your phone shipped with a messaging app that insists on sending long SMS messages as premium MMS âpictureâ messages, you might prefer to install this app which does not.âItâs open-source, tested with TalkBack and has a night mode.âItâs also able to send Unicode messages by default, unlike some preinstalled messaging apps that require this to be turned on in a setting misleadingly named âinput modeâ (actually transmission mode)
- If youâre stuck on Android 4.1 to 4.4 (which cannot run QKSMS) and need to send long messages, then your only option is probably an old version of Textra (its version 4.3 supported Android 4.1, and 4.5 supported Android 4.4) or ChompSMS (version 8.34 for Android 4.1, 8.55 for Android 4.4).
- 920 Text Editor (on Android 8 or below; APKs on GitHub, no longer on âPlay Storeâ): a small GPLd text editor that also tends to appear at the top of Simple Homeâs application list.âDoes not run on Android 9: try TwoSevenTwoâs âI<code> Goâ Code Editor (larger) instead [this was removed from Play Store in July 2020], or use the editor bundled with Speed Software Explorer but that one has smaller fonts, is more complex to start and has no syntax highlighting.âText editors are always useful: even if you wonât be editing, you might at some point need it for converting the clipboard contents to text (so it can be pasted into an application that does not do so itself) or to save something to a file, and 920 can also double as a rudimentary file manager if you donât have one.âItâs not Emacs though: its syntax highlighting is limited and itâs slow with large files.âBeware it can crash (for example, at least some versions crash when a Bluetooth keyboard is connected or in low-memory situations), so text that has not been saved is highly vulnerable.
- Speed Software Explorer: A file manager.âIf your device shipped with a non-advertising version of File Commander which later updated to one that advertises, or if you were annoyed when ES File Explorer started to promote festive âthemesâ on its Home screen and gambling games on its Apps screen, then you might prefer this one which was still without advertisements last time I checked.âCan also create shortcuts to specific files on the Home screen, provided that Simple Home is not running at the time of shortcut creation.â(Android 5+ can use Googleâs âFiles Goâ, which usually ships with Android 8+ by default, but you might still want Speed Software Explorer if Files Go is insufficient.)âCan read the âAndroid/dataâ directories of other apps in Android 4 through 10 but this was blocked in Android 11 (and their workaround didnât work for me on an Android 12 device).
- VLC (also on iOS): GPLâd media player with speed control and playlist navigation which is often lacking on manufacturersâ preinstalled players. (iOS version also has video-download functionality not present in iOSâs browser.)âYou might however wish to keep the old player installed as well, because MIDI files are not yet supported by all versions of VLC.âVLC became Android 4.2+ in April 2019; older versions are still available for 4.1 etc.
- AntennaPod: MIT-licensed âpodcastâ (audio RSS) client with variable-speed playback etc: can simplify download for sites using that format for audio articles.â(Version 2.5 increased the minimum Android requirement from 4.1 to 4.4.)
- Recent versions of iOS have a built-in âPodcastsâ app with similar functionality, but the âPodcastsâ app in iOSÂ 8 and below lacks the option to add your own URL
- VX ConnectBot (no longer on Play Store) or JuiceSSH: VX is Apache-licensed and supports port forwarding (might be needed for desktop SSH), but not password remembering for servers that donât âdoâ public-key authentication and its landscape mode might need manual configuration; Juice lacks these limitations but the unpaid version canât port-forward, and Version 3 began to require Android 8âon earlier devices youâll need an older APK.âVX has a built-in file uploader but this doesnât always work, and the scp command available on the local shell doesnât work in all Android versions, but you could use ssh -C user@host 'cat > filename' < filename or ssh user@host 'tar -c directory | xz -9' > downloaded.txz
- On Android 7+ (and *possibly* still working on 5 and 6 but I havenât tested this), you might prefer Termux for its more complete local shell with installable packages (including SSH, expect etc)âpinch to zoom; pull out multisession options from left; Paste option appears on long-press menu once text is available; you canât scroll during select so you must temporarily zoom out, and on smaller devices horizontal arrow keys require Hackerâs Keyboard to be set to 5-row; Play Store version currently not updating (pending a rewrite for new security rules) but still works.
- If you only have iOS, try Arnaud Mengusâs âWebSSH Essentialâ application (Arnaud was kind enough to add some larger fonts when I beta-tested).
- Organic Maps (also on iOS 12+ for iPhone 6+ etc): A fork of Maps.Me offline maps without the advertisements.
- In 2021 the package name was changed (and the old version is no longer supported by map-download servers); to update, you might have to back up your bookmarks, uninstall and reinstall.
- Android 4 might instead need Axet Maps (no longer on Play Store); to avoid crashes use the old version 9.1.8 of upstream Maps.Me to download maps from June 2019 and the same version of Axet to use them (donât update).âOn more recent Android please use Organic Maps to avoid problems with Axet.
- I didnât recommend the unmodified Maps.Me because I saw it carry advertising for scam get-rich-quick schemes and gambling apps, although that no longer seems to be their business model in 2023: in February they turned off most advertising on Android 6+ (except hotels and the wallet service), in June they limited downloads to 10 maps with a âproâ subscription to lift the limit, and in August they added a Product Hub.
- In places like Cambridge, OSM data tends to be better than Google data, e.g. for walking directions and building labels.âBut if you only need Google-level data, *their* Maps app now has âadvanced optionsâ to download areas of your choosing for offline use (with some exceptions e.g. mainland China), so you *could* just use that.â(In 2020 they moved these options to the âAccountâ menu at top right.)
- GPS Status & Toolbox (also on iOS; beware advertising): Provides (among other things) a way to force the phone to update its ephemeris data to give faster GPS fixes for a few days.âUseful because some design flaw made Androidâs automatic GPS management often insufficient and thereâs no way to force it in the systemâs own settings; older Android devices can become noticeably slow at acquiring GPS (if they manage to at all) without this utility.âThird-party advertising was added to the unpaid version at the end of December 2017; the last version not to have it was 8.0.168.âThen in April 2021 version 11 increased the minimum Android requirement to 8, so youâll likely need to side-load an older version for older devices.
- GPS Status & Toolbox can also read other sensors (Menu > Diagnose sensors), the most useful of which is the light-intensity sensor (in lux) which can help you check lamps for phosphor degradation.âThe âstep counterâ is less useful as it counts only when activated (and is reset on boot).
- Google PDF Viewer (no longer on Play Store): Does not require you to zoom out before turning pages as some bundled viewers do.âScrolls vertically; default zoom is page width.âIf you prefer horizontal scrolling with default zoom to full page, try MuPDF (AGPL, no longer on Play Store) which also reads EPUB etc.âOn Android 6+ you might prefer Adobe Acrobat Reader 21+ which has Liquid Mode (tries to reflow documents in big print, but doesnât always work) and a speech-synthesis button
- Google Docs: Can view Microsoft Word files offline (and tends to be faster and a bit smaller than Microsoftâs own app, unless that one came preinstalled on your device).âSome âchatâ apps (e.g. WeChat) *require* a .doc viewer to be installed before you can access any .doc file a contact might send youâthere is no option to save the file for later viewing on another device.
- Lithium EPUB Reader (Android 4.1+): Comparatively low resource requirements, night-theme option, font zooming (up to a point) and remembers your position when reloaded.âClosed-source but without advertisements last time I checked.âCan have trouble with wide tables (Annogen-generated apps like âPinyin Web Browserâ handle EPUBs with wide tables, but donât duplicate Lithiumâs other features like popup footnotes).
- CHM Reader X: Useful if you sometimes need to consult offline documentation in CHM format; this reader is faster than others when dealing with large files.âClosed-source but without advertisements last time I checked.âWhen dealing with framesets, you can show only one frame by editing Android/data/com.pdagate.chmreader/files/chmReaderState and changing page: (see text strings near start of chm file to figure out what to set it to), then bookmarking the result.âThen use this bookmark whenever you need to go back to the within-frame starting page (as the reader defaults to opening the last page visited).
- kWS (no longer on Play Store): Simple Web server suitable for sharing files over WiFi, which can be useful if Bluetooth is too slow or not working.âYouâll need to switch on âhotspotâ functionality (disable mobile data first if you donât want clients using up your quota); the IP and port that clients should browse to is displayed on kWS startup.âSome older devices (e.g. WM6) might not be able to connect to the hotspot, even in Open mode, due to subtle protocol changes over the years.âSome applications have their own WiFi-sharing functionality but that usually requires the same application to be installed on all devices; a Web server requires only a browser.
- Fractoid (Dave Byrne, no longer on Play Store): GPLâd fractal viewer, in case you ever need to explain the concept (but donât expect it to be as fast as XaoS on a desktop)
- EUMLab Pro Metronome (also on iOS): Useful for musicians if someone asks about tempo during a rehearsal and nobody has brought a metronome.âThis one is currently without advertisements but is closed source.âSubdivisions require a paid upgrade.
- K-9 Mail: Apache-licensed fork of the Android 4.4 email client with fewer problems (in particular, deleted messages are less likely to reappear on sync just because their flags are different on the server); has dark theme and configurable font sizes (may require restart), and a default folder can be set (useful when working with ImapFix).âOld version 5.6 or below is required for Android 4.x; OAuth 2 (now used by some âcloudâ email providers) has âwobblyâ support in version 6.2, or you might be able to set an âapp passwordâ (or on Android 5+ try âFairEmailâ which can do OAuth2 to GMail and also set default folders etc)
- Web Widget by Dennis Kempf: No longer maintained but still just about works on Android 10 if you want to display arbitrary information on the Home screen and are not running SimpleHome: works best when pointed at your own server so you can fully control the appearance from the server side, but beware it hard-codes a short timeout (so if writing a CGI make sure itâs fast even if widget updates are mostly non-interactive); it can refresh more frequently than asked and frequently clear its display due to timeout anyway.âAnd on Samsung phones it can set off spurious âbackground power drainâ alerts (but if âput to sleepâ it stops updating completely even when tapped)
- Alternatively on Android 6+ (5+ in pre-2023 versions) âKWGT Kustom [sic] Widget Makerâ can create a widget to fetch and display a piece of text, without markup, but without the timeout and load issues.âUse the wg command, set Items / Text / Type = Fixed Width, use a combination of that width value (which sets margins) and Layer / Scale (which sets size), and set touch action to Disabled (or to launch an app of your choice) if you donât want a single tap to bring you back to the edit screen.
- Beware of CamScanner Phone PDF Creator: Commercial software whose full version used to be available without charge via some universities (and became popular at Cambridge), but the developers have since been dangerously careless, resulting in remotely-controlled malware infections on both iOS and Android (and also the promotion of gambling).âThe fact that this happened *multiple* times caused me to feel the developers havenât learned and are likely to do it again.âIf you *must* use CamScanner, I suggest obtaining an APK for the old version 4.3.0 (2016-12-01), use it without registration (as itâs no longer supported by their servers), and, if possible, crop off the watermark on your scanned PDFs before showing them to others so as to avoid promoting a dangerous app.âBut there are alternatives:
- Android 7+ can run âMicrosoft Office LensâPDF Scannerâ and recent versions of this can process scans and create PDFs offline (the old Android 6 version requires a server which is probably no longer supplied, but you can use imagemagickâs convert command to concatenate them and create a PDF,
- and the âGoogle Driveâ app (which is often bundled by default) has a âScanâ option that can do both the image-processing *and* the PDF-assembly offline (even on Android 4.x), although of course it will also insist on uploading the PDF to its âDriveâ server as soon as there is a data connection.
You might like to try both and see which oneâs image-processing works best with your documents.
- Contacts Backup Ultimate (SpecSoft, no longer on Play Store): Useful if any of the deviceâs Contacts have higher-resolution (720x720) images: the standard Contacts application reduces their quality on export (at least up to Android 10).âBut the non-standard XML plus PNG backup will not easily import into another device without this app or a conversion script.âFor VCF format on Android 5+ there is âSuper Backupâ from MobileIdea Studio but beware (a) it plays noisy video advertisements that can flash (epileptics might want to look away from the screen) and (b) Android does not *internally* store contact images as JPEG, so exporting to that format is *not* suitable for repeated operationsâre-importing (perhaps after edits to the file) and re-exporting (after changes on the phone) will result in worse images than the first export, because the JPEG compression artefacts were converted back to bitmap and then re-encoded, so if you need repeated import-export then youâd better have your scripts take images from the earlier version when possible.â(It may also be advisable to take any TEL lines with PREF in them and place them before other TEL lines in the same VCARD, as some phones fail to import this attribute and just set the default number to the first one listed.)
- Samsung Internet: On phones (not tablets) running Android 5 and higher, recent versions of the Chrome web browser changed the tab switcher to a âgridâ version that significantly reduces the size of page previews, which is bad for low-vision accessibility.âThe ability to revert this using chrome://flags was disabled in Chrome 91 (May 2021), and Firefoxâs settable tab grid is only slightly less small.âIf you donât want to risk known-insecure older versions of Chrome, you could try Samsung Internet (its âtab stackâ does reduce the previewable area but doesnât shrink the font so much)âalso has a universal dark-mode switch, and its option to change text size takes fewer taps to reach (which can be useful if some bad web design makes a site impossible to navigate unless you temporarily reduce size and struggle; Chrome, Firefox and Ecosia have size settings under Accessibility which takes a little longer to reach).âSamsung Internet does sometimes have issues opening applications though and you might at least sometimes need to use Chrome.âIn new Chrome, at least tabs *within the same group* can be switched without preview by first scrolling up a little.
- Seconds Clock Widget (no longer on Play Store): Android versions 4.2 to 4.4 can add widgets to the lock screen; this one shows a seconds count with the time, which is not normally done by default, and is useful if you need to start a conference or something at an exact time and the wall clock is too far away to see.âOn newer versions of Android you might be able to get the seconds by tapping the clock on the lock screen, but this can vary with manufacturer.
- OS Monitor (Android 6 and older): GPLâd monitor of processes, network connections and logs: can be useful when diagnosing other applications with problems (can also look up the locations of servers theyâre connecting to, etc)
- Privacy Flashlight Lite (Android 4 and older, no longer on Play Store for the UK): No-nonsense torch (with âwidgetâ) for devices that have a camera light.âAndroid 5+ bundles this functionality.
- WangQiâs âMy Home Buttonâ (no longer on Play Store): Useful on older devices with worn-out hardware home buttons.âWhen I last checked, it sometimes had advertising on its Settings screen but mercifully not elsewhere.
- Onall QR Code Scanner No Ads (Android 4.2+, not currently on Play Store): Reads QR codes with comparatively little ânonsenseâ.âAndroid 9 and *some* Android 6+ devices bundle this functionality so wonât need this app.âAndroid 4.0 and 4.1 devices wonât be able to run Onallâs app and might be stuck with the advertisement-funded âQR Code Readerâ by âSustainable App Developerâ which lost its âNo Adsâ tag in November 2018âuse a version earlier than 1.1.9 (2021) if on 4.0 (and if you have to side-load an old version anyway then you might want to try one earlier than the version 1.0.7 that introduced advertisements).âThis latter app also has a zoom function which makes it more suitable for scanning QR codes at a distance.
You might also wish to check:
1. Your local transport authority or bus company (if you are a bus user), for example Cambridgeshireâs âMyBusTripâ (annoyingly listed under M by Simple Home; this can be worked around by assigning it a place on the dial-pad) presents the same data as on the bus stop signs, which might be useful if your stop lacks a sign or youâre not close enough to see it; some buses are actually tracked while others are just assumed to be in their timetabled locations.âSee also nextbuses.mobi although Iâm not sure if they always use the same data.
2. Your bank: they just might have an application that works better than their website (for some tasks), although few if any banks test on all versions of Android so donât be surprised if they break it
3. Any large marketplace site you sometimes happen to use (again their application might work better than their website for some tasks, but might break on some versions of Android)
4. Any large supermarkets you sometimes use for deliveries (same applies)
5. Your local library (some of them subscribe to digital audiobook services)
6. Any other large organisation(s) youâre associated with might have applications to expedite access to their servers and/or reading material, which might be worth checking (especially if they allow offline use)
7. Any âchatâ networks your contacts use (but beware of commercial licenses and data use)
Since at least Android 4.x, background data can be restricted per application in Settings (usually under Data Usage), and Android 9 finally implemented my suggestion of also allowing Wi-Fi connections to be limitedâuseful for connecting to âpersonal hotspotsâ etc.
âWi-Fi Callingâ on Android
âWiFi callingâ (the ability to route voice calls, and sometimes SMS messages, to and from your mobile-phone provider via WiFi when the building youâre in blocks their signal) is not a âstandardâ feature of Android, but is provided as an extra by certain manufacturers on certain devices.âTherefore there is no specific âminimum Android versionâ that supplies WiFi callingâyou have to choose from one of these particular models: Galaxy S6+, HTC 10+, Huawei P10+, Nexus 5X+/Pixel+, Xperia XZ1, E&OE, but beware Huawei phones made after late May 2019 no longer use the Google application store due to American trade sanctions.
- On some Android 9+ handsets (e.g. upgraded Galaxy S9), the option to enable Wi-Fi Calling is *hidden* until the mobile network sends the handset a secret code to âun-hideâ it.âThis is *different* from the general procedure of enabling Wi-Fi calling on your account, and not all call-centre employees understand the need to perform *both* operationsâso it may take *multiple* calls to technical support to get this fixed.â(For Vodafone UK, I found the âonline chatâ facility to be better at solving the problem than the call centre, but your mileage may vary.)
- Even if your mobile network supports voice-calling over WiFi, it might not also support SMS over WiFi.âBut if you have *very weak* phone signalâjust enough for messages but not enough for a voice callâthen you can have both phone and WiFi switched on and the device should route traffic appropriately.
- WiFi calling is not generally supported when you roam abroad (presumably because the system wonât âknowâ which country-code to default to).
The old âinTouchâ app from H3G UK ceased to be supported on 15th May 2019.âThis used to make WiFi-calling available on more devices (by carrying it separately from the phoneâs built-in dialler) and was a reason to choose the Three network on such devices, but this is no longer the case.
Sound-recorder applications on Android OS
Students recording lectures etc have generally moved from dedicated hardware to mobile âappsâ (applications).âBelow are my notes comparing some of the available alternatives on the Android platform.âUsual disclaimers apply.
I only list apps that:
1. Work in the background and/or with screen off (saving battery),
2. can record a long talk even in the unpaid version of the app.
Android 9 and above does not allow telephone calls to be recorded: any recording happening at the same time as a call will get silence for the duration of the call.âTherefore if you plan to both record a talk and call somebody to listen live, youâll need two separate devices (unless youâre running an older version or you managed to ârootâ it).
StereoMatch âAmazing MP3 Recorderâ
Pros:
- Works with screen readers
- Large controls, easy to operate (problems with early versions have been fixed)
- Visual indication of microphone pick-up on the left of the screen
Cons:
- Closed source (although currently without advertisements apart from suggestions to upgrade to Pro)
- If you donât like reading about voice changers and what people do with them, you might not appreciate some of the âwhatâs newâ updates (but there havenât been so many of these recently)
If you record OGG (MP3 encoding is a paid add-on but OGG is provided), the default settings give about 72Â kbps for speech (31M/hr, variable).
Onall Sound Recorder No Ads (removed from âPlay Storeâ in March 2019)
Pros:
- Unpaid version can record to MP3, which might be useful if you need to share the recording with someone who canât play OGG and you canât first get to a desktop to recode it (although recoding might still be a good idea for speech, as when set to 44.1k it seems to approximate lameâs --abr 80 setting)
- Decibel readout during recording (might be useful for making noise complaints?)
Cons:
- Closed source
- Small controls
- Switching off the screen during recording results in the app being backgrounded, which makes pause/stop take longer later
Triveous Voice Recorder
Pros:
- Visual indicator of microphone pick-up
Cons:
- Closed source
- Poor use of storage space.âAlthough Triveous *can* compress to AAC (or M4A in version 5; 128 kbps = 55M/hr, convertible via mplayer -ao pcm:file=output.wav or some installations of Audacity), it *also* makes an uncompressed WAV of the current track while encoding, so you need to allow space for this and/or keep each track short,
- and the old Version 3 even fails to delete them (for tracks exceeding about 18 minutes depending on hardware)âthis was fixed in Version 4, but the device still needs space for the WAV of each track while recording that track, regardless of the ârealtimeâ setting (non-realtime results in an extra encoding step taking about 50% of the recording time).
- If you *do* have space for WAV (3.3hr/G) then for distant sources itâs (usually) better to *just* use WAV and re-code it later, but this is no longer an option in version 5 which is M4A-only (but *still* has the âneed to leave room for the WAV as wellâ limitation that StereoMatch doesnât have).
- Triveous also requires Android 4.4 or above, so wonât work on old 4.1 phones like the Galaxy S2
Rehearsal Assistant (removed from âPlay Storeâ in December 2017)
Pros:
Cons:
- Serious bug when recording uncompressed (see its SourceForge Bug 4)âon some devices, if you do too much in other apps such as the browser, background recording can be aborted *without* clearing the red indicator on the notification bar, leaving an incomplete wav file that needs sox --ignore-length to play.
- For nearby sounds you could try the 48Â kbps AMR-NB .3gp (loadable in Audacity, mplayer etc) but the quality is lower.
iPhone ships with Voice Memos (possibly under Extras); this too works with the display switched off or in the background, and records 64kbit AAC (.m4a).âSome other iOS programs output .aif files that might need converting on a Mac.
Legal
All material © Silas S. Brown unless otherwise stated. Acrobat is an Adobe trademark. Adobe is a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated in the United States and/or other countries. Android is a trademark of Google LLC. Apache is a registered trademark of The Apache Software Foundation. Bluetooth is a registered trademark held by the Bluetooth Special Interest Group. Firefox is a registered trademark of The Mozilla Foundation. GitHub is a trademark of GitHub Inc. Google is a trademark of Google LLC. H3G is a trademark of Hutchison Whampoa Enterprises Limited. HTC and Touch are trademarks of HTC Corporation. Huawei is a trademark of Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd registered in China and other countries. iPhone is a trademark of Apple in some countries. Linux is the registered trademark of Linus Torvalds in the U.S. and other countries. Mac is a trademark of Apple Inc. Microsoft is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corp. MP3 is a trademark that was registered in Europe to Hypermedia GmbH Webcasting but I was unable to confirm its current holder. QR Code is the UK registered trademark of Denso Corporation. Samsung is a registered trademark of Samsung. SourceForge is a trademark of VA Software Corporation. Unicode is a registered trademark of Unicode, Inc. in the United States and other countries. Vodafone is a trademark of Vodafone Group Plc. WeChat is a trademark of Tencent Holdings Limited. Wi-Fi is a trademark of the Wi-Fi Alliance. Windows is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corp. Xperia is a trademark of Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB. Any other trademarks I mentioned without realising are trademarks of their respective holders.