💾 Archived View for gmi.noulin.net › mobileNews › 3380.gmi captured on 2023-06-16 at 19:31:57. Gemini links have been rewritten to link to archived content
⬅️ Previous capture (2023-01-29)
-=-=-=-=-=-=-
2011-09-14 11:57:39
Why are British children so unhappy? Four years after Unicef sparked national
soul-searching with analysis showing child well-being in the UK at the bottom
of a league of developed nations, the organisation has attempted to explain our
problem.
The answer, it seems, is that we put too little store on family time and too
much on material goods. Unicef paints a picture of a country that has got its
priorities wrong - trading quality time with our children for "cupboards full
of expensive toys that aren't used".
"Parents in the UK want to be good parents, but aren't sure how," the research
suggests. "They feel they don't have the time, and sometimes the knowledge, and
often try to compensate for this by buying their children gadgets and clothes."
The research compares Britain with Sweden and Spain. While the UK languishes in
21st, and last, place in the child well-being table, they come second and fifth
respectively.
One reason they perform so much better, according to Unicef, is that in both
countries "family time is protected" and children "all have greater access to
activities".
"In Sweden their social policy allows family time and their culture massively
reinforces it. In Spain fathers do work long hours, but the extended family is
still very important and women stay at home to look after their children."
The report argues that the pressure of the working environment and rampant
materialism combine to damage the well-being of our children. They want our
attention but we give them our money.
"All children interviewed said that material goods did not make them happy, but
materialism in the UK seems to be just as much of a problem for parents as
children," the research concludes. "Parents in the UK often feel compelled to
purchase consumer goods which are often neither wanted or treasured."
It is a profoundly depressing analysis of British life, not least because it
rings true.
Time poor
The importance of parents devoting energy and love to the rearing of their
children is accepted by political leaders from across the spectrum, but
maximising income and encouraging consumption are regarded as vital components
for economic growth.
In the UK, the demands of the latter often undermine the former.
Parents work all hours to increase family income but then are too exhausted or
too busy to give their children the attention they need and deserve.
Of course the Swedes and the Spanish are materialistic too, but the researchers
found parents in these countries more able to defy the consumer society.
"Parents in the UK don't know how to challenge the materialist culture they
see around them. This is in stark contrast to the families the researchers
spent time with in Sweden and Spain."
One reason for Britain's poor performance, it is suggested, is that material
inequality is much higher here than in other rich countries. This chart from
another Unicef report card published last November shows the UK with a far
wider gap in material well-being than the OECD average.
The consequence is that poorer families feel they have to struggle even harder
to get their children the stuff that is equated to status: the latest computer
games, branded trainers and corporate logos.
"Parents and children feel massive external pressure from a materialistic
culture, which they know won't bring happiness, but are conforming to
none-the-less," the research finds. "Lack of family time and materialism is
particularly felt among poorer families in the UK compared to the other
countries."
Another problem is that British teenagers do not have enough to do -
particularly within the educational arena.
"In the UK, children's time in active creative pursuits diminishes in secondary
schools compared to children in Spain and Sweden. This is particularly true
among older, deprived children in the UK."
Unicef's remedy is for Britain to look at its priorities. They want politicians
to consider specific measures to support families:
reform of advertising laws
a living wage so that families earn enough to spend more time with each other
protection of children's facilities so they have the opportunity to be active
Before the last election, David Cameron gave a speech in which he said that
"what matters most to a child's life chances is not the wealth of their
upbringing but the warmth of their parenting."
Today's Unicef research would seem to concur. If Britain is serious about doing
the best for its children, it needs to give them more time not more stuff.