💾 Archived View for gmi.noulin.net › mobileNews › 2176.gmi captured on 2023-06-16 at 20:21:57. Gemini links have been rewritten to link to archived content

-=-=-=-=-=-=-

iPhone feels the heat from Droid X factor

2010-07-02 11:27:15

While the world continues to line up for the latest iPhone reception problems

and all Verizon's just-announced jumbo-screen Motorola Droid X has racked up

a bevy of admiring reviews.

David Pogue at the New York Times calls the Droid X (slated to arrive July 15

for $199, with a two-year Verizon Wireless contract and after a mail-in rebate)

a "big, beautiful contender" with an "almost-Imax screen" (4.3 inches

diagonally, to be exact, or almost a inch bigger than the iPhone's 3.5-inch

display). The phone performs like a "speed rocket," Pogue gushes, and benefits

from Google's "open and customizable" (and soon Flash-supporting) Android OS,

although he also complains about a few nagging quirks (the security warnings

before you download Android apps, the wonky screen rotation, the Wi-Fi-less

Skype).

The Droid X battery "gets you through a full day easily," Pogue continues, and

there's also Verizon's "expensive but not-call-dropping network," as well as

the handset's ability to act as a mobile hotspot for other Wi-Fi devices. That

said, the Droid X isn't for everyone, Pogue warns, saying that the "absolutely

huge" shell makes you feel "as if you're talking into a frozen waffle" when

you're making a call, and that although Android is a great OS for "technically

proficient high-end users," it's "more complicated and less polished" than

Apple's iOS.

CNET's Bonnie Cha calls the Droid X a "beast, but in a good way," citing the

"brilliant" display, the "responsive" performance (although "not quite as

lightning-fast as the Droid Incredible"), and 7.5 hours of talk time. Snapshots

from the X's 8-megapixel camera yielded "mixed" results "nice" pictures

interspersed with "blurry shots" despite the auto-focus feature although

recorded 720p video clips "looked great." Cha also praises the phone's

"great"-sounding call quality on Verizon's "mostly reliable" network, and wraps

up the four-star (out of five) review by calling the Droid X a "formidable

competitor" in the summer smartphone wars.

Then there's Ed Baig at USA Today, who just last week called the iPhone "the

one to beat." Baig's sticking to his guns about the iPhone, but he calls the

"highly customizable" Droid X an "impressive, feature-packed" handset that has

"good" call quality ("I never had a dropped call"), a "mammoth" display and a

healthy collection of apps in the Android Marketplace. Baig dings the X for its

lack of a front-facing camera for video chat but says its photo quality is

"decent" and the Android-powered Web browser is "excellent." Overall, Baig

calls the X a "terrific smartphone" that "will give the iPhone 4 a run for its

money."

Finally, we've got PC Magazine's Sascha Segan, who dubs the Droid X a "Hummer

humdinger" that's "excellent" if "a little excessive" "big iron" that's

nevertheless "relatively thin and light," with a screen is "beautiful to look

at." Segan deems call quality and reception "spectacular" (though not

"perfect") thanks to the phone's trio of microphones and "huge" antennas.

The Droid X's speedy 1GHz OMAP processor also garners high marks from Segan,

although he wonders if Motorola's custom social networking-friendly Motoblur

interface (which, apparently, you can't disable) isn't a "drag on performance."

And though Segan praises the X's camera quality ("one of the best I've seen on

a phone") and HD video capture, he slams the handset's HD video-out support

which is only compatible with the photo and video galleries, and not YouTube or

the included Blockbuster movie app as "a tease and a cheat." In the end,

though, Segan grants the X the Editors' Choice award among Verizon smartphones:

4.5 (out of five) stars.

Overall, some strong reviews for yet another summertime superphone and let's

not forget the quartet of upcoming new Android handsets from Samsung, all with

4-inch Super AMOLED displays and 1GHz processors, as well as the wildly popular

HTC Evo 4G that went on sale earlier this month (which, given all the

smartphone news we've seen in June, feels like a lifetime ago). Looks like the

iPhone 4 has some serious competition on its hands.

So, smartphone shoppers, which of this summer's superphones will you pick: the

iPhone 4, the Droid X, the Evo 4G or a Samsung Galaxy phone? Or is there

another smartphone contender on your list?

Ben Patterson is a technology writer for Yahoo! News.