💾 Archived View for spam.works › mirrors › textfiles › politics › 3wash.txt captured on 2023-06-16 at 19:55:07.
-=-=-=-=-=-=-
14 page printout, page 37 to 50 of 225
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
GEORGE WASHINGTON.
During the presidential campaign of 1880, the Christian Union
made the startling admission that, of the nineteen men who, up to
that time, had held the office of President of the United States,
not one, with the Possible exception of Washington, had ever been
a member of a Christian church.
Was Washington a church member? Was he in any sense a
Christian? In early life he held a formal adherence to the church
of England, serving, for a time, as a vestryman in the parish in
which he resided. But this being merely a temporal office did not
necessitate his being a communicant, nor even a believer in
Christianity. In his maturer age he was connected with no church.
Washington, the young Virginia planter, might, perhaps, with some
degree of truthfulness, have been called a Christian; Washington,
the Soldier, statesman and sage, was not a Christian, but a Deist.
This great man, like most men in public life, was reticent
respecting his religious views. This rendered a general knowledge
of his real belief impossible, and made it easy for zealous
Christians to impose upon the public mind and claim him for their
faith. Whatever evidence of his unbelief existed was, as far as
possible, suppressed. Enough remains, however, to prompt me to
attempt the task of proving the truth of the following
propositions:
1. That Washington was not a Christian communicant.
2. That he was not a believer in the Christian religion.
WAS WASHINGTON A COMMUNICANT?
Washington was not a communicant. This fact can be easily
demonstrated. A century ago it was the custom of all classes,
irrespective of their religious beliefs, to attend church.
Washington, adhering to the custom, attended. But when the
administration of the sacrament took place, instead of remaining
and partaking of the Lord's Supper as a communicant would have
done, he invariably arose and retired from the church.
The closing years of his life, save the last two, were passed
in Philadelphia, he being then President of the United States. In
addition to his eight years' incumbency of the presidency, he was,
during the eight years of the Revolutionary war, and also during
the six years that elapsed between the Revolution and the
establishment of the Federal government, not only a frequent
visitor in Philadelphia, but during a considerable portion of the
time a resident of that city. While there he attended the Episcopal
churches of which the Rev. William White and the Rev. James
Abercromble were rectors. In regard to his being a communicant, no
evidence can be so pertinent or so decisive as that of his pastors.
Bishop White, the father of the Protestant Episcopal church of
America, is one of the most eminent names in church history. During
a large portion of the period covering nearly a quarter of a
century, Washington, with his wife, attended the churches in which
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
37
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
Bishop White officiated. In a letter dated Fredericksburg, Aug. 13,
1835, Colonel Mercer sent Bishop White the following inquiry
relative to this question:
"I have a desire, my dear Sir, to know whether Gen.
Washington was a communicant of the Protestant Episcopal
church, or whether he occasionally went to the communion only,
or if ever he did so at all. ... No authority can be so
authentic and complete as yours on this point."
To this inquiry Bishop White replied as follows:
"Philadelphia, Aug. 15, 1835.
"Dear Sir: In regard to the subject of your inquiry, truth
requires me to say that Gen. Washington never received the
communion in the churches of which I am the parochial minister.
Mrs. Washington was an habitual communicant.
... I have been written to by many on that point, and
have been obliged to answer them as I now do you. I am
respectfully.
"Your humble servant,
"WILLIAM WHITE."
(Memoir of Bishop White, pp. 196, 197).
In a standard Christian authority, Sprague's "Annals of the
American Pulpit," written and compiled by Rev. Wm. B. Sprague,
D.D., is a sketch of the life of Rev. James Abercromble, D.D. In
this biographical sketch is to be found some very important
evidence from the pen of Washington's other pastor, pertaining to
the subject under consideration. I quote the following:
"One incident in Dr. Abercrombie's experience as a
clergyman, in connection with the Father of his Country, is
especially worthy of record; and the following account of it
was given by the Doctor himself, in a letter to a friend, in
1831 shortly after there had been some public allusion to it:
'With respect to the inquiry you make I can only state the
following facts; that, as pastor of the Episcopal church,
observing that, on sacramental Sundays, Gen. Washington,
immediately after the desk and pulpit services, went out with
the greater part of the congregation -- always leaving Mrs.
Washington with the other communicants -- she invariably being
one -- I considered it my duty in a sermon on Public Worship,
to state the unhappy tendency of example, particularly of
those in elevated stations who uniformly turned their backs
upon the celebration of the Lord's Supper. I acknowledge the
remark was intended for the President; and as such he received
it. A few days after, in conversation with, I believe, a
senator of the United States, he told me he had dined the day
before with the President, who in the course of conversation
at table said that on the preceding Sunday he had received a
very just reproof from the pulpit for always leaving the
church before the administration of the Sacrament; that he
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
38
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
honored the preacher for his integrity and candor; that he had
never sufficiently considered the influence of his example,
and that he would not again give cause for the repetition of
the reproof; and that, as he had never been a communicant,
were he to become one then it would be imputed to an
ostentatious display of religious zeal? arising altogether
from his elevated station. Accordingly, he never afterwards
came on the morning of sacramental Sunday, though at other
times he was a constant attendant in the morning'" (Annals of
the American Pulpit, Vol. v, p. 394).
Here we have a confirmation of the statement previously made
that Washington absented himself from church on sacramental
Sundays; undeniable proof that during the later years of his life
he was not a communicant; and, above all, the assurance of
Washington himself that "he had never been a communicant."
The Rev. E.D. Neill, in the Episcopal Recorder, the organ of
the church of which it is claimed Washington was a communicant,
says:
"As I read, a few days ago, of the death of the Rev.
Richard M. Abercrombie, rector of St. Matthew's Protestant
Episcopal church in Jersey City, memories of my boyhood arose.
He was born not far from my father's house in Philadelphia and
was the son of the Rev. James Abercrombie, a fine scholar and
preacher, who had in early life corresponded with the great
lexicographer, Dr. Samuel Johnson, and in later years was the
assistant minister of Christ's and St. Peter's churches, in
Philadelphia, where my maternal ancestors had worshiped for
more than one generation. One day, after the father had
reached four score years, the lately deceased son took me into
the study of the aged man, and showed me a letter which
President George Washington had written to his father,
thanking him for the loan of one of his manuscript sermons.
Washington and his wife were regular attendants upon his
ministry while residing in Philadelphia. The President was not
a communicant, notwithstanding all the pretty stories to the
contrary, and after the close of the sermon on sacramental
Sundays, had fallen into the habit of retiring from the church
while his wife remained and communed."
Referring to Dr. Abercrombie's reproof of Washington, Mr.
Neill says:
"Upon one occasion Dr. Abercromble alluded to the unhappy
tendency of the example of those dignified by age and position
turning their backs upon the celebration of the Lord's Supper.
The discourse arrested the attention of Washington, and after
that he never came to church with his wife on Communion
Sunday."
The Rev. Dr. Wilson, in his famous sermon on the Religion of
the Presidents, also alludes to this subject. He says:
"When the Congress sat in Philadelphia, President
Washington attended the Episcopal church. The rector, Dr.
Abercrombie, told me that on the days when the sacrament of
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
39
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
the Lord's Supper was to be administered, Washington's custom
was to rise just before the ceremony commenced, and walk out
of church. This became a subject of remark in the
congregation, as setting a bad example. At length the Doctor
undertook to speak of it, with a direct allusion to the
President. Washington was heard afterwards to remark that this
was the first time a clergyman had thus preached to him, and
he should henceforth neither trouble the Doctor nor his
congregation on such occasions; and ever after that, upon
communion days, he 'absented himself altogether from the
church.'
The Rev. Bird Wilson, D.D., author of the "Memoir of Bishop
White," says:
"Though the General attended the churches in which Dr.
White officiated, whenever he was in Philadelphia during the
Revolutionary war, and afterwards while President of the
United States, he never was a communicant in them" (Memoir of
Bishop White, p. 188).
The Rev. Beverly Tucker, D.D., of the Episcopal church, has
attempted to prove that Washington was a churchman. But while
professing to believe that he was a communicant before the
Revolution he is compelled to admit that there is a doubt about his
communing after the Revolution. He says:
"The doubt has been raised partly on the strength of a
letter written by Bishop White in 1832. He says that
Washington attended St. Peter's church one winter, during the
session of the Continental Congress, and that during his
Presidency he had a pew in Christ church, 'which was
habitually occupied by himself, by Mrs. Washington, who was
regularly a communicant, and by his secretaries. This language
is taken to mean, and probably correctly, that Washington did
not commune."
Dr. Tucker is evidently not acquainted with Bishop White's
letter to Col. Mercer in 1835. There is no question as to the
meaning of that letter. Continuing, Dr. Tucker says:
"The doubt rests again on the recollection of Mrs.
Fielding Lewis, Nelly Custis, Gen. Washington's step-
granddaughter, written in 1833, who states that after the
Mount Vernon family removed from Pohick church to Christ
church, Alexandria, the General was accustomed, on Communion
Sundays, to leave the church with her, sending the carriage
back for Mrs. Washington."
Washington's biographer, the Rev. Jared Sparks, who seems to
have entertained the popular notion that Washington was in early
life a communicant, admits that at a latter period he ceased to
commune. He says:
"The circumstance of his withdrawing himself from the
communion service at a certain period of his life has been
remarked as singular. This may be admitted and regretted, both
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
40
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
on account of his example and the value of his opinions as to
the importance and practical tendency of this rite" (Life of
Washington, Vol. ii, p. 361).
Origen Bacherer, in his debate with Robert Dale Owen in 1831,
made an effort to prove that Washington was a Christian
communicant. He appealed for help to the Rev. Wm. Jackson, rector
of the Episcopal church of Alexandria, the church which Washington
had attended. Mr. Jackson was only too willing to aid him. He
instituted an exhaustive investigation for the purpose of
discovering if possible some evidence of Washington having been a
communicant. Letters of inquiry were addressed to his relatives and
friends. But his efforts were unsuccessful. While he professed to
believe that Washington was a Christian, he was compelled to say:
"I find no one who ever communed with him" (Bacheler-Owen
Debate, Vol. ii, p. 262).
This, as might be supposed, did not satisfy Mr. Bacherer, and
he entreated the rector to make another attempt. The second attempt
was as fruitless as the first.' He writes:
"I am sorry after so long a delay in replying to your
last, that it is not in my power to communicate something
decisive in reference to General Washington's church
membership" (Ibid., ii, p. 370.)
In the same letter Mr. Jackson says:
"Nor can I find any old person who ever communed with
him."
The "People's Library of Information" contains the
following:
"The question has been raised as to whether any one of
our Presidents was a communicant in a Christian church.
There is a tradition that Washington asked permission of a
Presbyterian mister in New Jersey to unite in communion. But
it is only a tradition. Washington was a vestryman in the
Episcopal church. But that office required no more piety
than it would to be mate of a ship. There is no account of
his communing in Boston, or in New York, or Philadelphia, or
elsewhere, during the Revolutionary struggle."
The tradition of Washington's wishing to unite with a
Presbyterian minister in communion, like many other so-called
traditions of the same character, has been industriously
circulated. And yet it is scarcely possible to conceive of a more
improbable story. Refusing to commune with the members of the
church in which he was raised, and the church he was in the habit
of attending, and going to the priest of another church -- a
stranger -- and asking to commune with him! Had Washington been
some intemperate vagabond, the story might have been believed.
But Washington was not an inebriate, and was never so pressed for
a drink as to beg a sup of sacramental wine from a Calvinistic
clergyman.
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
41
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
Gen. A.W. Greely, U.S.A., in an article on "Washington's
Domestic and Religious Life" which was published in the Ladies'
Home Journal for April, 1896, says:
"But even if he was ever confirmed in its [the
Episcopal] faith there is no reliable evidence that he ever
took communion with it or with any other church."
Some years ago, I met at Paris, Texas, an old gentlemen, Mr.
F.W. Miner, who was born and who lived for a considerable time
near Mt. Vernon. He told me that when a boy he was once in
company with a party of old men, neighbors in early life of
Washington, who were discussing the question of his religious
belief. He says that it was admitted by all of them that he was
not a church member, and by the most of them that he was not a
Christian.
Mr. George Wilson of Lexington, Mo., whose ancestors owned
the Custis estate, and founded Alexandria, where Washington
attended church, writes as follows: "My great-grandmother was
Mary Alexander, daughter of 'John the younger,' who founded
Alexandria. The Alexander pew in Christ church was next to
Washington's, and an old lady, a kinswoman of mine, born near
Alexandria and named Alexander, told me that the tradition in the
Alexander family was that Washington NEVER took communion."
In regard to Washington being a vestryman, Mr. Wilson says:
"At that time the vestry was the county court, and in order to
have a hand in managing the affairs of the county, in which his
large property lay, regulating the levy of taxes, etc.,
Washington had to be a vestryman."
The St. Louis Globe contained the following in regard to the
church membership of Washington:
"It is a singular fact that much as has been written
about Washington, particularly with regard to his superior
personal virtue, there is nothing to show that he was ever a
member of the church. He attended divine service, and lived
an honorable and exemplary life, but as to his being a
communicant, the record is surprisingly doubtful."
In an article conceding that Washington was not a
communicant, the Western Christian Advocate says:
"This is evident and convincing from the Life of Bishop
White, bishop of the Episcopal church in America from 1787
to 1836. Of this evidence it has been well said: 'There does
not appear to be any such undoubtable evidence existing. The
more scrutinously the church membership of Washington is
examined, the more doubtful it appears. Bishop White seems
to have had more intimate relations with Washington than any
clergyman of his time. His testimony outweighs any amount of
influential argumentation on the question.'
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
42
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
The following is a recapitulation of the salient points in
the preceding testimony, given in the words of the witnesses. It
is in itself an overwhelming refutation of the claim that
Washington was a communicant:
"Gen. Washington never received the communion in the
churches of which I am the parochial minister." -- Bishop
White.
"On sacramental Sundays, Gen. Washington, immediately
after the desk and pulpit services, went out with the
greater part of the Congregation." -- Rev. Dr. Abercromble.
"After that, [Dr. Abercrombie's reproof,] upon communion
days, he absented himself altogether from the church." -- Rev.
Dr. Wilson.
"The General was accustomed, on communion Sundays, to
leave the church with her [Nelly Custis], sending the
carriage back for Mrs. Washington. " -- Rev. Dr. Beverly
Tucker.
"He never was a communicant in them [Dr. White's
churches]." -- Rev. Dr. Bird Wilson.
"I find no one who ever communed with him." -- Rev.
William Jackson.
"The President was not a communicant." -- Rev. E.D.
Neill.
"This [his ceasing to commune] may be admitted and
regretted." -- Rev. Jared Sparks.
"There is no reliable evidence that he ever took
communion." -- Gen. A.W. Greely.
"There is nothing to show that he was ever a member of
the church." -- St. Louis Globe.
"I have never been a communicant." -- Washington,
quoted by Dr. Abercrombie.
The claim that Washington was a Christian communicant must
be abandoned; the claim that he was a believer in Christianity, I
shall endeavor to showy is equally untenable.
WAS WASHINGTON A CHRISTIAN?
In the political documents, correspondence, and other
writings of Washington, few references to the prevailing religion
of his day are found. In no instance has he expressed a disbelief
in the Christian religion, neither can there be found in all his
writings a single sentence that can with propriety be construed
into an acknowledgment of its claims. Once or twice he refers to
it in complimentary terms, but in these compliments there is
nothing inconsistent with the conduct of a conscientious Deist.
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
43
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
Religions, like their adherents, possess both good and bad
qualities, and Christianity is no exception. While there is much
in it deserving the strongest condemnation, there is also much
that commands the respect and even challenges the admiration of
Infidels. Occupying the position that Washington did, enjoying as
he did the confidence and support of Christians, it was not
unnatural that he should indulge in a few friendly allusions to
their religious faith.
In his "Farewell Address," the last and best political paper
he gave to the Christian religion is not once named. In this work
he manifests the fondest solicitude for the future of his
country. His sentences are crowded with words of warning and
fatherly advice. But he does not seem to be impressed with the
idea that the safety of the government or the happiness of the
people depends upon Christianity. He recommends a cultivation of
the religious sentiment, but evinces no partiality for the
popular faith.
In the absence of any recorded statements from Washington
himself concerning his religious belief, the most conclusive
evidence that can be presented is the admissions of his clerical
acquaintances. Among these there has been preserved the testimony
of his pastors, Bishop White and Dr. Abercromble.
In a letter to Rev. B.C.C. Parker of Massachusetts, dated
Nov. 28, 1832, in answer to some inquiries respecting
Washington's religion, Bishop White says:
"His behavior [in church] was always serious and attentive,
but as your letter seems to intend an inquiry on the point of
kneeling during the service, I owe it to the truth to declare
that I never saw him in the said attitude. ... Although I was
often in company with this great man, and had the honor of dining
often at his table, I never heard anything from him which could
manifest his opinions on the subject of religion. ... Within a
few days of his leaving the presidential chair, our vestry waited
on him with an address prepared and delivered by me. In his
answer he was pleased to express himself gratified by what he had
heard from our pulpit; but there was nothing that committed him
relatively to religious theory" ("Memoir of Bishop White," pp.
189-191; Sparks' "Life of Washington," Vol. ii., p. 359).
The Rev. Parker, to whom Bishop White's letter is addressed,
was, it seems, anxious to obtain some evidence that Washington
was a believer in Christianity, and, not satisfied with the
bishop's answer, begged him, it would appear, to tax his mind for
some fact that would tend to show that Washington was a believer.
In a letter dated Dec. 21, 1832, the bishop writes as follows:
"I do not believe that any degree of recollection will
bring to my mind any fact which would prove General
Washington to have been a believer in the Christian
revelation further than as may be hoped from his constant
attendance upon Christian worship, in connection with the
general reserve of his character" ("Memoir of Bishop White,"
p. 193).
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
44
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
Bishop White's testimony does not afford positive proof of
Washington's unbelief, but it certainly furnishes strong
presumptive evidence of its truth. It is hardly possible to
suppose that he could have been a believer and have let his most
intimate Christian associates remain in total ignorance of the
fact. Bishop White indulges a faint hope that he may have been,
but this hope is simply based on his "constant attendance" at
church, and when we consider how large a proportion of those who
attend church are unbelievers, that many of our most radical
Freethinkers are regular church-goers, there are very small
grounds, I think, upon which to indulge even a hope. But even
this "constant attendance" on the part of Washington cannot be
accepted without some qualification; for, while it is true that
he often attended church, he was by no means a constant
attendant. Not only did he uniformly absent himself on communion
days, but the entries in his diary show that he remained away for
several Sundays in succession, spending his time at home reading
and writing, riding out into the country, or in visiting his
friends.
But if Bishop White cherished a faint hope that Washington
had some faith in the religion of Christ, Dr. Abercrombie did
not. Long after Washington's death, in reply to Dr. Wilson, who
had interrogated him as to his illustrious auditor's religious
views, Dr. Abercrombie's brief but emphatic answer was:
"Sir, Washington was a Deist."
Washington rarely attended, as we have seen, any church but
the Episcopal, hence, if any denomination of Christians could
claim him as an adherent, it was this one. Yet here we have two
of its most distinguished representatives, pastors of the
churches which he attended, the one not knowing what his belief
was, the other disclaiming him and asserting that he was a Deist.
The Rev. Dr. Wilson, who was almost a contemporary of our
earlier statesmen and presidents, and who thoroughly investigated
the subject of their religious beliefs, in his sermon already
mentioned affirmed that the founders of our nation were nearly
all Infidels, and that of the presidents who had thus far been
elected -- George Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, James
Madison, James Monroe, John Quincy Adams, and Andrew Jackson --
not one had professed a belief in Christianity. From this sermon
I quote the following:
"When the war was over and the victory over our enemies
won, and the blessings and happiness of liberty and peace
were secured, the Constitution was framed and God was
neglected. He was not merely forgotten. He was absolutely
voted out of the Constitution. The proceedings, as published
by Thompson, the secretary, and the history of the day, show
that the question was gravely debated whether God should be
in the Constitution or not, and, after a solemn debate he
was deliberately voted out of it. ... There is not only in
the theory of our government no recognition of God's laws
and sovereignty, but its practical operation, its
administration, has been conformable to its theory. Those
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
45
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
who have been called to administer the government have not
been men making any public profession of Christianity. ...
Washington was a man of valor and wisdom. He was esteemed by
the whole world as a great and good man; but he was not a
professing Christian."
Dr. Wilson's sermon was published in the Albany Daily
Advertiser in 1831, and attracted the attention of Robert Dale
Owen, then a young man, who called to see its author in regard to
his statement concerning Washington's belief. The result of his
visit is given in a letter to Amos Gilbert. The letter is dated
Albany, November 13, 1831., and was published in New York a
fortnight later. He says:
"I called last evening on Dr. Wilson, as I told you I
should, and I have seldom derived more pleasure from a short
interview with anyone. Unless my discernment of character
has been rievously at fault, I met an honest man and sincere
Christian. But you shall have the particulars. A gentleman
of this city accompanied me to the Doctor's residence. We
were very courteously received. I found him a tall,
commanding figure, with a countenance of much benevolence,
and a brow indicative of deep thought, apparently
approaching fifty years of age. I opened the interview by
stating that though personally a stranger to him, I had
taken the liberty of calling in consequence of having
perused an interesting sermon of his, which had been
reported in the Daily Advertiser of this city, and regarding
which, as he probably knew, a variety of opinions prevailed.
In a discussion, in which I had taken a part, some of the
facts as there reported had been questioned; and I wished to
know from him whether the reporter had fairly given his
words or not. ... I then read to him from a copy of the
Daily Advertiser the paragraph which regards Washington,
beginning, 'Washington was a man,' etc., and ending,
'absented himself altogether from the church.' 'I indorse,'
said Dr. Wilson, with emphasis, 'every word of that. Nay, I
do not wish to conceal from you any part of the truth, even
what I have not given to the public. Dr. Abercrombie said
more than I have repeated. At the close of our conversation
on the subject his emphatic expression was -- for I well
remember the very words -- 'Sir, Washington was a Deist.'"
In concluding the interview, Dr. Wilson said: "I have
diligently perused every line that Washington ever gave to the
public, and I do not find one expression in which he pledges
himself as a believer in Christianity. I think anyone who will
candidly do as I have done, will come to the conclusion that he
was a Deist and nothing more.),
In February, 1800, a few weeks after. Washington's death,
Jefferson made the following entry in his journal:
"Dr. Rush told me (he had it from Asa Green) that when
the clergy addressed General Washington, on his departure
from the government, it was observed in their consultation
that he had never, on any occasion, said a word to the
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
46
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
public which showed a belief in the Christian religion, and
they thought they should so pen their address as to force
him at length to disclose publicly whether he was a
Christian or not. However, he observed, the old fox was too
cunning for them. He answered every article of their address
particularly, except that, which he passed over without
notice" (Jefferson's Works, Vol. iv., p. 572).
Jefferson further says: "I know that Gouverneur Morris, who
claimed to be in his secrets, and believed himself to be so, has
often told me that General Washington believed no more in that
system [Christianity] than he did" (Ibid).
Gouverneur Morris was the principal drafter of the
Constitution of the United States; he was a member of the
Continental Congress, a United States senator from New York, and
minister to France. He accepted, to a considerable extent, the
skeptical views of French Freethinkers.
The "Asa" Green mentioned by Jefferson was undoubtedly the
Rev. Ashbel Green, chaplain to Congress during Washington's
administration. In an article on Washington's religion,
contributed to the Chicago Tribune, B.F. Underwood says:
"If there were an Asa Green in Washington's time he was
a man of no prominence, and it is probable the person
referred to by Jefferson was the Rev. Dr. Ashbel Green, who
served as chaplain to the Congress during the eight years
that body sat in Philadelphia, was afterwards president of
Princeton College, and the only clerical member of Congress
that signed the Declaration of Independence. His name shines
illustriously in the annals of the Presbyterian church in
the United States."
Some years ago I received a letter from Hon. A.B. Bradford
of Pennsylvania, relative to Washington's belief. Mr. Bradford
was for a long time a prominent clergyman in the Presbyterian
church, and was appointed a consul to China by President Lincoln.
His statements help to corroborate the statements of Dr. Wilson,
Thomas Jefferson, and Mr. Underwood. He says:
"I knew Dr. Wilson personally, and have entertained him
at my house, on which occasion he said in my hearing what my
relative, the Rev. Dr. Ashbel Green of Philadelphia,
frequently told me in his study, viz., that during the time
that Congress sat in that city the clergy, suspecting from
good evidence that Washington was not a believer in the
Bible as a revelation from heaven, laid a plan to extort
from him a confession, either pro or con, but that the plan
failed. Dr. Green was chaplain to Congress during all the
time of its sitting in Philadelphia; dined with the
President on special invitation nearly every week; was well
acquainted with him, and after he had been dead and gone
many years, often said in my hearing, though very
sorrowfully, of course, that while Washington was very
deferential to religion and its ceremonies, like nearly all
the founders of the Republic, he was not a Christian, but a
Deist."
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
47
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
Mr. Underwood's article contained the following from the pen
of Mr. Bradford:
"It was during his [Dr. Green's] long residence in
Philadelphia that I became intimately acquainted with him as
a relative, student of theology at Princeton, and a member
of the same Presbytery to which he belonged. Many an hour
during my student and clergyman days did I spend with him in
his study at No. 150 Pine street, Philadelphia, listening to
his interesting and instructive conversation on
Revolutionary times and incidents. I recollect well that
during one of these interviews in his study I inquired of
him what were the real opinions Washington entertained on
the subject of religion. He promptly answered pretty nearly
in the language which Jefferson says Dr. Rush used. He
explained more at length the plan laid by the clergy of
Philadelphia at the close of Washington's administration as
President to get his views of religion for the sake of the
good influence they supposed they would have in
counteracting the Infidelity of Paine and the rest of the
Revolutionary patriots, military and civil. But I well
remember the smile on his face and the twinkle of his black
eye when he said: 'The old fox was too cunning for Us.' He
affirmed, in concluding his narrative, that from his long
and intimate acquaintance with Washington he knew it to be
the case that while he respectfully conformed to the
religious customs of society by generally going to church on
Sundays, he had no belief at all in the divine origin of the
Bible, or the Jewish-Christian religion."
The testimony of General Greely, whose thorough
investigation of Washington's religious belief makes him an
authority on the subject, is among the most important yet
adduced. From his article on "Washington's Domestic and Religions
Life" I quote the following paragraphs:
"The effort to depict Washington as very devout from
his childhood, as a strict Sabbatarian, and as in intimate
spiritual communication with the church is practically
contradicted by his own letters."
"In his letters, even those of consolation, there
appears almost nothing to indicate his spiritual frame of
mind. A particularly careful study of the man's letters
convinces me that while the spirit of Christianity, as
exemplified in love of God and love of man [Theophilauthropy
or Deism], was the controlling factor of his nature, yet he
never formulated his religious faith."
"It is, however, somewhat striking that in several
thousand letters the name of Jesus Christ never appears, and
it is notably absent from his last will."
"His services as a vestryman had no special
significance from a religious standpoint. The political
affairs of a Virginia county were then directed by the
vestry, which, having the power to elect its own members,
was an important instrument of the oligarchy of Virginia."
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
48
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
"He was not regular in attendance at church save
possibly at home. While present at the First Provencal
Congress in Philadelphia he went once to the Roman Catholic
and once to the Episcopal church. He spent four mouths in
the Constitutional Convention, going six times to church,
once each to the Romish high mass, to the Friends', to the
Presbyterian, and thrice to the Episcopal service."
"From his childhood he traveled on Sunday whenever
occasion required. He considered it proper for his negroes
to fish, and on that day made at least one contract. During
his official busy life Sunday was largely given to his home
correspondence, being, as he says, the most convenient day
in which to spare time from his public burdens to look after
his impaired fortune and estates."
Dr. Moncure D. Conway, who made a study of Washington's life
and character, who had access to his private papers, and who was
employed to edit a volume of his letters, has written a monograph
on "The Religion of Washington," from which I take the following:
"In editing a volume of Washington's private letters
for the Long Island Historical Society, I have been much
impressed by indications that this great historic
personality represented the Liberal religious tendency of
his tune. That tendency was to respect religious
organizations as part of the social order, which required
some minister to visit the sick, bury the dead, and perform
marriages. It was considered in nowise inconsistent with
disbelief of the clergyman's doctrines to contribute to his
support, or even to be a vestryman in his church."
"In his many letters to his adopted nephew and young
relatives, he admonishes them about their manners and
morals, but in no case have I been able to discover any
suggestion that they should read the Bible, keep the
Sabbath, go to church, or any warning against Infidelity."
"Washington had in his library the writings of Paine,
Priestley, Voltaire, Frederick the Great, and other
heretical works."
Conway says that "Washington was glad to have Volney as his
guest at Mount Vernon," and cited a letter of introduction which
Washington gave him to the citizens of the United States during
his travels in this country.
In a contribution to the New York Times Dr. Conway says:
"Augustine Washington, like most scholarly Virginians
of his time, was a Deist. ... Contemporary evidence shows
that in mature life Washington was a Deist, and did not
commune, which is quite consistent with his being a
vestryman. In England, where vestries have secular
functions, it is not unusual for Unitarians to be vestrymen,
there being no doctrinal subscription required for that
office. Washington's letters during the Revolution
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
49
SIX HISTORIC AMERICANS -- GEORGE WASHINGTON.
occasionally indicate his recognition of the hand of
Providence in notable public events, but in the thousands of
his letters I have never been able to find the name of
Christ or any reference to him."
There is no evidence to show that Washington, even in early
life, was a believer in Christianity. The contrary is rather to
be presumed. His father, as Dr. Conway states, was a Deist; while
his mother was not excessively religious, His brother, Lawrence
Washington, was, it is claimed, the first advocate of religious
liberty in Virginia, and evidently an unbeliever, so that instead
of being surrounded at home by the stifling atmosphere of
superstition, he was permitted to breathe the pure air of
religious freedom.
It is certain that at no time during his life did he take
any special interest in church affairs. Gen. Greely says that "He
was not regular in church attendance save possibly at home." At
home he was the least regular in his attendance. His diary shows
that he attended about twelve times a year. During the week he
Superintended the affairs of his farm; on Sunday he usually
attended to his correspondence. Sunday visitors at his house were
numerous. If he ever objected to them it was not because they
kept him from his devotions, but because they kept him from his
work. In his diary he writes:
"It hath so happened, that on the last Sundays -- call
them the first or seventh [days] as you please, I have been
unable to perform the latter duty on account of visits from
strangers, with whom I could not use the freedom to leave
alone, or recommend to the care of each other, for their
amusement."
When he visited his distant tenants to collect his rent,
their piety, and not his, prevented him from doing the business
on Sunday, as the following entry in his diary shows:
"Being Sunday, and the people living on my land very
religious, it was thought best to postpone going among them
till to-morrow."
His diary also shows that he "closed land purchases, sold
wheat, and, while a Virginia planter, went fox hunting on
Sunday."
He did not, like most pious churchmen, believe that
Christian servants are better than others. When on one occasion
he needed servants, he wrote:
"If they are good workmen, they may be from Asia,
Africa, or Europe; they may be Mahomedans, Jews, or
Christians of any sect, or they may be Atheists."
These extracts contain no explicit declarations of disbelief
in Christianity, but between the lines we can easily read, "I am
not a Christian."
**** ****
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
Bank of Wisdom
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
50