💾 Archived View for republic.circumlunar.space › users › dbane › gemlog › 2021-10-17.gmi captured on 2023-05-24 at 18:10:57. Gemini links have been rewritten to link to archived content

-=-=-=-=-=-=-

A Review of MUD Tech

Long, long ago I used to play btmux and that got me curious enough to learn the software and even submit a few patches. In many ways, there is an alternate universe where the most popular application-level protocol for the Internet is derived from MUDs rather than HTTP.

I find some features of these servers interesting:

Ordinary non-privileged users can write programs
Transparent persistence
Real-time I/O, not the HTTP (and 3270) form submission semantics (although this changed for the Web with AJAX)
It's somewhat after MUDs' heyday, but there are simple protocols layered on text chat for more structured and domain-specific tasks, e.g. MCP & MSDP

Here I give some opinions on code I've looked into. Note that there are many more systems I never learned. However, consider this a hint as to where to start; it's best to avoid going down one of the many, many dead ends that have been written over the nearly 40 years of MUD development.

BTMux

Servers

I've gone through a sequence of reading & learning from the source code of several different projects. After all this my current favourite is ToastCore/ToastStunt. Rather a fundamental redesign, this is an incremental addition to LambdaMOO, which is probably the most popular "serious" MUD server. ToastStunt is popular (for a MUD) and well-maintained. You can log into ChatMUD to see a live instance.

ToastCore/ToastStunt

ChatMUD

Clients

My current favourite client is rmoo. It implements MCP local editing which is very nice for editing MOO code. Also extensible in ELisp, but I haven't got that far yet.

rmoo

Extended Protocols

Most MUDs use the telnet protocol, i.e. IAC WILL/WONT, state machines, etc. I looked into some extensions layered on top of this:

MCP was the first. It is associated with MOO-family servers. It even has some useful extensions for "serious" things.
Followed by MSDP. This seems to be more associated with combat MUD games. It typically communicates HP/MP/gold. However, of more interest is that an Intermud network was implemented on top of it.

MCP

MSDP

Arachnos, Intermud over MSDP

Historical Notes

I've been playing with software like this for some time. Here are notes on alternatives that I rejected. This section can be skipped.

Servers

TinyMUX. This is a rock-solid piece of software that implements the "MUSHCode" language, which is idiosyncratic but interesting as a (very) domain-specific language.
ColdCore/genesis. This was a project to engineer things properly, a nice C-like language with extensions for security, compiler, bytecode interpreter. Not as popular as it deserved to be though, and I can't see that it's used any more.

TinyMUX

ColdCore/genesis

Clients

TinyFugue. This used to be very popular and there are interesting client-side macros for it (e.g. MCP). But it seems to be unmaintained nowadays.
TinTin++. This is probably a better choice nowadays for a terminal-mode client. It also has a full scripting language in which, e.g. MSDP was implemented

Then I started trying to use Emacs more, which led me to

mu.el. This is scriptable in ELisp, but I never got far with it before switching to rmoo (see above).