💾 Archived View for gemini.spam.works › mirrors › textfiles › groups › CDC › cDc-0277.txt captured on 2023-01-29 at 14:58:17.
⬅️ Previous capture (2020-11-01)
-=-=-=-=-=-=-
_
| \
| \
| | \
__ | |\ \ __
_____________ _/_/ | | \ \ _/_/ _____________
| ___________ _/_/ | | \ \ _/_/ ___________ |
| | _/_/_____ | | > > _/_/_____ | |
| | /________/ | | / / /________/ | |
| | | | / / | |
| | | |/ / | |
| | | | / | |
| | | / | |
| | |_/ | |
| | | |
| | c o m m u n i c a t i o n s | |
| |________________________________________________________________| |
|____________________________________________________________________|
...presents... RUSH TO JUDGEMENT
Why the World Won't End in September, 1994
by Omega
and Reid Fleming
>>> a cDc publication.......1994 <<<
-cDc- CULT OF THE DEAD COW -cDc-
____ _ ____ _ ____ _ ____ _ ____
|____digital_media____digital_culture____digital_media____digital_culture____|
Homo vult decipi; decipiatur
"Man wishes to be deceived; deceive him."
______________________________________________________________________________
August 24, 1994
The Second Coming of Christ refers to the Christian belief in the future
return of Christ in glory to judge the living and the dead, an event that will
end the present world order. Although the Bible never uses the term Second
Coming, in Hebrews 9:28 the hope of Christ appearing a second time is
expressed. This hope originated in the Easter experiences of the apostles,
which communicated a sense of the incompleteness of Christ's work and the
promise of its future completion. Early Christians expressed these convictions
by identifying the resurrected Christ with the Son of Man (Dan. 7:13) and by
combining this text with Ps. 110:1 (as in Mark 14:62). At first, the Christian
community expected an imminent return of Christ, but it adjusted itself with
remarkable ease to the notion of an indefinitely postponed Second Coming.
That notion has proved especially convenient in our era, as several have
set dates for the Second Coming of Christ.
After a detailed examination of the books of Daniel and Revelation,
William Miller became convinced that the Second Coming of Christ would occur
sometime in 1843. Thousands, converted by his teachings in the early 1830s,
began to prepare for Christ's return. As 1843 passed without incident, Miller
specified first March 21, 1844, and later October 22, 1844, as dates for the
event. Despite the serious setbacks dealt by the failure of these predictions,
the movement Miller inspired continued, eventually re-forming as the Seventh
Day Adventists. The Seventh Day Adventist Church would later give rise to
several splinter groups, including the Branch Davidians who, under the
leadership of David Koresh, were especially pre-occupied with the end of the
world.
Charles Russell expected the church to be Raptured before October, 1914
(shortly after the beginning of the first World War).
Edgar Whisenant thought the Rapture would take place in 1988. Evidence
seems to suggest that it did not.
Flyers pasted to the girders of the I-93 Expressway near Faneuil Hall in
Boston still warn that the Rapture will take place September 28, 1992.
Joseph Smith, prophet of the Mormons, instructed his chosen people about
the end times, with a caveat:
Were I going to prophesy, I would say the end
[of the world] would not come in 1844, 5 or 6,
or in forty years. There are those of the rising
generation who shall not taste death till Christ
comes.
I was once praying earnestly upon this
subject, and a voice said unto me, "My son, if
thou livest until thou art eighty-five years of
age, thou shalt see the face of the Son of Man."
I was left to draw my own conclusions concerning
this, and I took the liberty to conclude that if
I did live to that time, He would make His
appearance. ... I prophesy in the name of the Lord
God, and let it be written -- the Son of Man will
not come in the clouds of heaven till I am
eighty-five years old (48 years hence or about 1890).
Interestingly, for Joseph Smith the world _did_ end in 1844, at the
hands of an angry mob in Carthage, Illinois.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (the Mormons) have since
updated their prophecy. The Mormons believe that God lives on or near planet
Kolob, purportedly in our galaxy, and that a single day on Kolob is precisely
one thousand years on Earth (possibly a reference to II Peter 3:8). At the
beginning of the seventh day on Kolob, the events foretold in the Book of
Revelation will unfold on Earth. According to the Mormons, the earth is
slightly less than six thousand years old, fixing day seven on Kolob to begin
around the year 2000 AD by our reckoning.
As we near the end of a century and, more significantly, the end of a
millennium, the doomsday rumblings have become louder and more frequent:
Whatever you do, DON'T DISREGARD THIS WARNING.
Don't hope that this is just an idle threat.
Don't argue with yourself that your church
and/or your pastor do not teach this. Don't
listen to the scientists who insist so
confidently that this universe is millions
or billions of years old.
The likelihood of September, 1994 being the very
end of this world is so very great that the alarm
must be taken very seriously.
With that, Family Radio president and general manager Harold Camping - the
latest in a succession of men to fix the date of the Second Coming - introduces
his latest book, _Are You Ready?_, the sequel to his epochal work _1994?_. Mr.
Camping warns that he is "far more than 99% certain. There's a great amount of
evidence to be considered and anybody who doesn't look at this seriously is at
enormous risk." Camping continues:
During the past year as many students of the
Bible have been carefully examining the ideas and
conclusions set forth in the book _1994?_, one would
think that if these conclusions are [sic] in error
there would be an increasing sense of uneasiness
in the hearts of many. There would be a feeling and
a growing awareness that this whole study is somehow
incorrect in that there are too many inconsistencies,
too many 'far-fetched' ideas, too much speculation.
The fact is, however, just the opposite has
been the case. Individual after individual has
written to me or talked with me offering further
corroboration, further Biblical evidence that
validates the conclusion of the extreme likelihood
of the end of the world sometime in September, 1994.
His report of many positive testimonials, if true, can only be an
indictment of the public's gullibility. In truth, Harold Camping's claims are
riddled with inconsistencies, far-fetched ideas and speculation bordering on
fantasy. To anyone bothering to look into Camping's prophecies this would be
plain. It amazes us anyone could proudly and with some success pass such
third-rate sophistry off as Biblical prophecy.
Unlike Mr. Camping, few of the doomsayers who have come before him have
had the benefit of the media to propagate their misinformation. Thanks to
Family Radio's network of 67 affiliate stations, short-wave radio, his
ministry's many pilgrimages to other countries and the availability of his
books in large bookstore chains, Harold Camping's message is carried almost as
easily across the world as it is across the country. (A little publicity
couldn't hurt book sales and pledge drives!) The technology which enables this
kind of communication is also implicitly responsible for legitimizing the
message it communicates. The tendency on the part of the public is to accept,
without thoughtful examination, something that is presented as factual in print
or over radio and television. In the months that we have been listening to Mr.
Camping's call-in show "Open Forum" we cannot recall having heard any of his
callers challenge him on the basis of anything in his books.
For a single moment, Harold Camping glimpses the psychology of the
failures who have come before him. Of the other charlatans, Camping has this
to say:
Throughout history mankind has asked this question.
Because he is created in the image of God, he senses
that there will be a time when he must answer to God
for the manner in which he has lived his life.
Usually, when the trauma he or his nation is enduring
is especially terrible, both in its size as well
as in its duration of time, he begins to wonder
if 'doomsday,' as he frequently expresses it, has
almost come.
The Plague, for instance, which killed an estimated one-quarter to
one-third of Europe's population during the Middle Ages, was thought to be a
judgment from God signaling the end of the world.
Not too surprisingly, Camping fails to see the same psychology at work
in his own mind. The astute reader can see it, though, in the record of
Camping's prophecy. Inadvertently, _1994?_ and _Are You Ready?_ have become
projective psychological tests on Harold Camping. Besides women in the clergy
and a dearth of hell-and-damnation preaching in Christendom, what else is
terribly wrong with the world according to him? What wish fulfillment of his
will happen as a result of the earth's wickedness? Read on. _Are You Ready?_
in particular is the fascinating journal of Harold Camping's Rorschach
interpretations of the Bible.
We accept the challenge which, by Camping's account, no one else would
accept. As it is written in the _Bovinomicon_, "the gauntlet thrown in
challenge that cannot be borne up by hand must be lifted by righteous hoof."
As it is written, so shall it be done!
As time allows, we will evaluate the great amount of evidence Camping
cites and the enormous and impending peril the earth is certain to face in a
few short days.
In citing Biblical passages, we often use the New International Version
and indicate it with (NIV) in the citation; in particular we do so when Camping
himself does not supply the KJV quotation for a particular passage. Unlike
Camping, we prefer a translation which is thorough, annotated and unencumbered
by a cryptic and archaic form of English.
______________________________________________________________________________
There are four parts to Camping's thesis:
I. SEVEN SIGNS PORTENDING THE END OF THE WORLD
II. THE JUBILEE YEAR
1994 is a Jubilee Year, beginning in September.
III. NUMEROLOGY
Numbers in the Bible have symbolic meaning.
IV. NUMEROLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF SIGNIFICANT TIME-PATHS
Particular biblical stories form a time-line; when
the difference between the dates of the stories
and the crucifixion, birth of Christ, or 1994 is
factored into numerologically significant numbers,
it _proves_ 1994 is the end of the world.
I. SEVEN SIGNS PORTENDING THE END OF THE WORLD
----- ----- ---------- --- --- -- --- -----
The Bible speaks of several signs which are in evidence in the end times.
Camping identifies seven signs in particular, a few of which are worth
commenting on.
1. ISRAEL BECOMES A NATION
Matthew 24:32-33
Now learn a parable of the fig tree; When his
branch is yet tender, and putteth forth leaves,
ye know that summer is nigh: So likewise ye,
when ye shall see all these things, know that
it is near, even at the doors.
Most Biblical scholars and Camping concur: the fig tree is (in this case)
a metaphor for Israel; the fig tree putting forth leaves appears to describe
Israel becoming a nation in 1948.
2. FALSE PROPHETS HAVE ARISEN
Matthew 24:24
For there shall arise false Christs, and
false prophets, and shall shew great
signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it
were possible, they shall deceive the very
elect.
To this Camping adds, "...let it suffice us to say that never before has
there been such a worldwide interest in signs and wonders, that is, in
miracles, as there is in the present day. The dramatic rise in interest and
involvement with the matter of miracles is clearly given as a sign that the end
of the world is almost here." Interestingly, this passage says nothing about
an _increased interest_ in signs and wonders; it says that false prophets will
arise who will evidence great signs and wonders. These great signs and wonders
are a consequence of the false prophets, not the other way around.
Nevertheless, Camping offers no proof of his statement here, (although
he alludes to the proof being found in his previous book, _1994?_); his promise
of its verity does _not_ suffice. How Camping is able to quantify his claim is
beyond us. For that matter, never before has there been such a world-wide
interest in sex as there is in the present day! You could marshal all sorts of
evidence on either side of that argument, but essentially the premise is
unproveable, as Camping's is, and about as meaningful.
3. THE FALLING AWAY
Camping refers to II Thessalonians 2:3 for the third and fourth signs
being in evidence. In this instance, he speaks of the 'falling away' of man
from the true Gospel: "The Bible increasingly is no longer the final authority.
It has become supplanted by the church and the ideas of men as the ultimate
authority. ... The Gospel that is preached to a high degree has degenerated
into a religion that is pleasing to the ears of men."
II Thessalonians 2:1-3 (NIV)
Concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ
and our being gathered to Him, we ask you,
brothers, not to become easily unsettled or
alarmed by some prophecy, report or letter
supposed to have come from us, saying that the
day of the Lord has already come. Don't let
anyone deceive you in any way, for that day
will not come until the rebellion occurs
and the man of lawlessness is revealed,
the man doomed to destruction.
II Thessalonians' reference to the rebellion is not believed to be a
reference to the falling away from the faith, rather the Apostle Paul is
speaking of active rebellion, supreme opposition of evil to the things of God.
Matthew 24:10-12 and I Timothy 4:1, however, do mention the falling away
specifically, and are perhaps more appropriate attributions for this sign.
4. THE ANTICHRIST
Camping tells us the fourth sign is that the man of sin is revealed:
"Throughout the New Testament era, it was fairly generally taught that the man
of sin spoken of in II Thessalonians 2 would be some great political or
religious (or a combination of both) world leader. Thus, in his day, Kaiser
Wilhelm was spoken of as the Antichrist. Earlier than that one of the popes of
the Roman Catholic Church was regarded as the Antichrist. During the Second
World War, Hitler and Mussolini shared the spotlight as being the Antichrist.
But in every instant [sic] these conclusions proved false because the world
continued on its way." 20/20 hindsight is wonderful, isn't it?
At this point, Camping reveals the identity of the man of sin to us:
"However, in our day, we have come to know without question who the Antichrist
is. Through His Word, God the Holy Spirit has revealed that _Satan_ is the
Antichrist [Emphasis added]."
Laughable! This common-sensical tautologism, though irrefutable, is
redundant and hardly revelatory. Similarly profound revelations can be made,
for instance: "The Messiah has been revealed to be... the Lamb of God," or "The
next President of the United States will be... the man who's elected in 1996."
5. RUNNING TO AND FRO
Camping indicates the fifth sign in the language of Daniel 12:4:
But thou, O Daniel, shut up the words, and seal
the book, even to the time of the end: many shall
run to and fro, and knowledge shall be increased.
Camping instructs that this verse has to do with "the scarcity of the true
Gospel in the world at the end of time. ... Thus, [they] are running to and fro
looking for truth." The true Gospel seems to have been a moving target for
most of the last two millennia, so it's difficult to say whether there is an
even greater scarcity of the true Gospel today.
"Additionally," Camping explains, "in their quest for truth, frequently
they are seeking for it in places removed from the Gospel. Such activities as
the New Age movement and similar occult practices attest to this." Like
numerology?
6. KNOWLEDGE SHALL INCREASE
Camping again refers to Daniel 12:4 for the sixth sign. "Amongst those
that are saved," Camping says, "there is a great increase in the understanding
of the Bible." And with a bit of self-important gall, he adds: "For example, a
great many of the teachings declared in the book _1994?_ and in this sequel to
it have been known to believers only in the last few years." Evidently, the
information supplied in Harold Camping's last two books help fulfill Biblical
prophecy.
7. HOMOSEXUALITY; AIDS IS A PLAGUE FROM GOD
Camping spends a good deal of time on the seventh and final sign that
evidences the end times.
"A seventh sign that shows in dramatic fashion that we are at the end of
the world is the fact that the homosexuals have come out of the closet, that
is, they openly boast of their sin. ... Today, homosexuality is increasingly
being taught and practiced as an alternative lifestyle that should be
acceptable to all people. ... One would think that when the plague of AIDS
began to sweep through the world, being evidenced to a high degree in the
homosexual community, that this would so shame those who practiced this sin
that they would again hide themselves from the eyes of the public ... As we
indicated in _1994?_ (pages 207-214), the AIDS plague which was predicted in
Romans 1:24-27, serves two very important purposes. They are:
"1. The AIDS plague together with the fact that homosexuality is
increasingly being accepted as a viable lifestyle is a dramatic
sign that the world is ripe for judgment.
"2. It is a judgment predicted in the Bible which can readily be
seen by all men, thus indicating the Bible's predictions
concerning future judgments do come true. In like manner, the
repeated predictions of the Bible concerning the judgment of
the last day will also certainly come to pass."
Curiously, Romans 1:24-27 (NIV) doesn't mention a plague:
Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires
of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading
of their bodies with one another. They exchanged
the truth of God for a lie, and worshipped and
served created things rather than the Creator --
who is forever praised. Amen.
Because of this, God gave them over to shameful
lusts. Even their women exchanged natural
relations for unnatural ones. In the same way
the men also abandoned natural relations with
women and were inflamed with lust for one another.
Men committed indecent acts with other men, and
received in themselves the due penalty of their
perversion.
God allows sin to run its course as an act of judgment; in the context of
Romans 1:24-27, God's judgment _clearly_ does not involve plagues. Romans 1
continues:
Furthermore, since they did not think it worthwhile
to retain the knowledge of God, he gave them over
to a depraved [the intent precedes the act] mind,
to do what ought not to be done.
But completely aside from the lack of any scriptural evidence of a plague
against homosexuals, let's examine more closely the suggestion that AIDS could
be a plague from God against homosexuals.
While it is true that in the United States, male homosexuals were
initially the hardest hit, AIDS is not a homosexual disease. In fact,
according to _AIDS Update 1993_, Gerald J. Stine notes: "The proportion of
HIV infection and AIDS cases among the heterosexual population in the United
States is now increasing at a greater rate than the proportion of HIV infection
and AIDS cases among homosexuals or IDU's (Friedland, 1987)." Why should a
"[homosexual] plague which was predicted in Romans 1:24-27" afflict
heterosexuals (moreso now than homosexuals, especially in Africa and Asia),
intravenous drug users and blood-transfusion patients? For that matter, why
should a plague from God afflict the innocent - for instance: the unborn, or
blood-transfusion patients (who aren't necessarily homosexual or even sexually
active)? According to scripture, God's judgments have singled out the wicked
exclusively. In the story of Sodom and Gomorrah, Abraham poses the same
question we do:
Genesis 18:23 (NIV)
Then Abraham approached [the Lord] and said:
"Will you sweep away the righteous with the
wicked? What if there are fifty righteous
people in the city? Will you really sweep it
away and not spare the place for the sake
of the fifty righteous people in it? Far be it
from you to do such a thing - to kill the
righteous with the wicked, treating the righteous
and the wicked alike. Far be it from you!
Will not the Judge of all the earth do right?"
Abraham was confident God would do what was right, and intervened on
behalf of his relatives and the righteous still left in Sodom.
And what about practicing lesbians? In their book _Human Sexuality_, the
noted researchers Masters, Johnson and Kolodny remark: "While the Old Testament
is specific about male homosexuality (Leviticus 18:22, 20:13), female
homosexual behavior is not mentioned."
If AIDS is truly a plague from God, He seems to have a soft spot in His
heart for lesbians (that is, lesbians who are exclusively homosexual and are
not also intravenous drug users), who are the least at risk of any sexually-
active group. _AIDS Update 1993_ reports: "Female-to-female transmission has
been reported in one case and suggested in another (Curran, 1988). As with
other sexually transmitted diseases, HIV transmission among lesbians is very
low." A study published in this month's British medical journal _Lancet_ lends
further credence to this conclusion.
Camping also draws on Luke 17:28-30 to emphasize God's judgment against
homosexuals:
Likewise also as it was in the days of Lot; they
did eat, they drank, they bought, they sold, they
planted, they builded; But the same day that Lot
went out of Sodom it rained fire and brimstone
from heaven, and destroyed them all. Even thus
shall it be in the day when the Son of man is
revealed.
Camping adds: "Mysteriously in our day the identical sin that was boldly
practiced in Sodom just before its destruction is boldly being practiced all
over the world." However, in the preceding paragraph, Luke 17:26 (NIV), Jesus
says:
Just as it was in the days of Noah, so also will
it be in the days of the Son of Man. People
were eating, drinking, marrying and being given
in marriage up to the last day Noah entered the
ark. Then the flood came and destroyed them all.
Jesus is drawing a parallel between the destruction that resulted with the
flood (an episode which did not specifically feature homosexuality) and the
destruction of Sodom: judgment of the wicked on the day the Son of Man is
revealed; judgment which takes the wicked by surprise. Only by taking Luke
17:28-30 out of context can a judgment singling out homosexuals be suggested.
In the light of fact, Camping's claims for the seventh sign seem
apocryphal. The "judgment predicted in the Bible which can readily be seen by
all men" fails to materialize.
II. THE JUBILEE YEAR
--- ------- ----
The seven signs, if they are actually appearing, signal that we are in the
end times. Is the Bible more specific about the season of Christ's return?
Camping and others think so and direct our attention to Leviticus 25 and
Leviticus 27. There we read about the observance of the Jubilee year:
Leviticus 25:8
And thou shalt number seven sabbaths of years unto
thee, seven times seven years; and the space of
the seven sabbaths of years shall be unto thee
fourty and nine years. Then shalt thou cause
the trumpet of the jubile to sound on the tenth
day of the seventh month, in the day of atonement
shall ye make the trumpet sound throughout all
your land. And ye shall hallow the fiftieth year,
and proclaim liberty throughout all the land unto
all the inhabitants thereof: it shall be a jubile
unto you; and ye shall return every man unto his
possession, and ye shall return every man unto
his family. A jubile shall that fiftieth year
be unto you.
The Jubilee year reminded the Jews that the Lord had ultimate ownership
of the land he had given them in Canaan; the land had been given to them
through no merit of their own and hence was not theirs to use for unrestrained
personal gain. Because of the provisions of the Jubile, contracts were not
binding in perpetuity, and land was "owned" for fifty years at a time at most.
Camping compares the significance of the Jubilee year with Christ's second
coming: debts are forgiven on the Jubilee year and with our spiritual
salvation, our debt of sin is forgiven; on the Jubilee year, the land returns
to its original owner and with Christ's second coming, the meek inherit the
earth; in the year of Jubilee, slaves are given their liberty and with Christ's
return, the earth and the true believers are delivered from the bondage of
corruption and sin.
Determining the year of the Jubilee is contingent on knowing when the
Israelites entered the land of Canaan and observance of the Jubile became
mandatory. From Camping's very careful study, he concludes the Jews entered
Canaan in 1407 BC. Camping says 1407 BC was a sabbath year and beginning 1406
BC, six years were counted off until the next sabbath year occurred in 1400 BC.
The next sabbath years, according to Camping, were 1393 BC, 1386 BC, 1379 BC,
1372 BC, 1365 BC and 1358 BC followed by the Jubilee in 1357 BC. Accounting
for the lack of a year 0 AD, Camping's figures lead us to 1944 AD and 1994 AD
being Jubilee years.
However, the language of Leviticus 25 does not seem to indicate that the
first year was a sabbath year:
Leviticus 25:2 (NIV)
When you enter the land which I give you, the
land shall keep sabbaths to the Lord. For six
years you may sow your fields and for six years
prune your vineyards and gather the harvest,
but in the seventh year the land shall keep a
sabbath of sacred rest, a sabbath to the Lord.
Though the language of the King James Version of this passage is slightly
different (and Camping seems to depend on the KJ version), only when it is
taken out of context can the assumption be made that the year the Jews entered
Canaan was a sabbath year:
Leviticus 25:2 (KJV)
Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto
them, When ye come into the land which I give you,
then shall the land keep a sabbath unto the LORD.
Six years thou shalt sow thy field, and six years
thou shalt prune thy vineyard, and gather in the
fruit thereof; ...
Assuming 1407 BC was in fact the year the Jews entered Canaan, if that
year was not a sabbath year then the next Jubilee year was 1351 BC, not 1357
BC., which would lead us to 1950 AD and 2000 AD being Jubilee years.
Marilyn J. Agee, who has her own end-of-the-world theory and has also
written a book, has a different perspective on the calculation of the Jubilee:
_The End of the Age: The Secret of Secrets Revealed_, pg 254:
Many mistakes have been made in figuring the Jubilee.
Some thought crops had to grow in the land for 49
years before keeping Jubilee because they were to
keep it after they entered the land of Canaan.
That doesn't seem necessary.
The Jubilee cycle is 49 years: the 50th year
is the first of the next cycle. The cycles began
Nisan 1, 1530 BC, the year of the Exodus. ...
Knowing the Jubilee would begin Nisan 1 should have
told us a long time ago that Christ would return on Nisan 1.
She also disagrees with Camping about the year the Jews entered Canaan;
she believes the date to be 1530 BC. Incidentally, Ms. Agee believes Christ
will return April 6, 2008. (She also believes that Satan lives on an asteroid
named Rahab which will impact earth in the end times.)
The best authority on when the Jubile is celebrated would be the Jews
themselves. We have been unable to contact rabbinical scholars to confirm the
date, so let's accept Camping's account. It makes no difference, really, since
Camping is predisposed toward the year 1994.
Camping also draws on the episode of the siege of Jericho. The Hebrew
word for Jubilee is "yobhel", which means "ram's horn" - the horn that is blown
to usher in the Jubilee. Recall that the Jews surrounded the walled city of
Jericho, circling it once a day until on the seventh day they circled the city
seven times then blew the ram's horn and shouted and Jericho's walls fell flat.
Camping suggests a connection between the thirteen times Jericho is encircled
by the Jews and the roughly 13,000 years he says elapse between the creation
(in 11,013 BC) and the second coming of Christ. Camping also says the
destruction of Jericho relates to the Jubilee of 1994 when Christ will return
to lay siege to the earth and its sinful inhabitants. Lastly, Camping points
to the similarity of the shouting and trumpeting at Jericho to I Thessalonians
4:16 which mentions that Christ will return "with a shout... and with the trump
of God."
"Jubilee," Camping says, "identifies with judgment even as the judgment at
the end of the world is in a Jubilee year."
When is the season of the second coming?
In all probability it could be on September 15,
which is the date for the day of atonement in 1994.
...it also could be sometime during the feast of
tabernacles which follows from September 20 to
September 27. ... but the evidence shows that in
all likelihood it must be from the earliest on
September 15, the day of atonement, to no later
than September 27, the last day of the feast of
tabernacles.
However, a CNN Headline News segment on August 8th quoted Camping as
pin-pointing the date as September 6. Why he has contradicted himself is
uncertain, but don't let it ruin your labor day weekend.
III. SPIRITUAL SIGNIFICANCE OF NUMBERS IN THE BIBLE
--------- ------------ -- ------- -- --- -----
Please bear with us: the length of this section is directly related to its
importance in Camping's scheme.
II Timothy 3:16:
All scripture is given by inspiration of God,
and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof,
for correction, for instruction in righteousness
II Peter 1:20 (NIV):
Above all, you must understand that no prophecy
of Scripture came about by the prophet's own
interpretation. For prophecy never had its
origin in the will of man, but men spoke from
God as they were carried along by the Holy
Spirit.
THE MYSTERY OF NUMBERS
Those two passages form the basis of Mr. Camping's third thesis. The
prophets tell us every word, every phrase of the Bible is authored by God.
Camping reminds us, "included in these words that were God-breathed are all of
the numbers found in the Bible. They are just as important and just as much
the Word of God as any other word recorded in the Bible. ... A disregard for
the significance of the numbers of the Bible is bound to limit our
understanding of some aspects of the Gospel message."
This seems, for the most part, a fair-enough assumption. While God
sometimes uses phrases like "many," "great," "multitude," "large," and "small,"
to convey size, He often uses specific numbers. He speaks of the 14,700 who
die in the plague He sends against rebellious Israelites; the 153 fish of John
21:11; the 276 men shipwrecked in Acts 27:37; the giant circular bowl outside
Solomon's temple which is 30 cubits in circumference.
In addition to recording size or amounts, Camping argues that numbers
found in the Bible are often symbolic and convey spiritual information; they
"embellish and enrich the Gospel message." God _does_ seem to use numbers
symbolically, especially in the book of Revelation (10 horns on the Dragon,
etc.) But more specifically, it is Camping's belief that "God has placed many
numbers in the Bible to give us _precise_ understanding of the timetable of the
earth [emphasis added]." Camping tells us this timetable can be projected
forward to give the date of the Second Coming of Christ. (More on this in
section IV.)
THE PLENARY VERBAL INERRANCY OF THE BIBLE
Camping's third thesis rests on the belief in the plenary verbal inerrancy
of the Bible: God is infallible and the Bible is the Word of God ("men...were
carried along by the Holy Spirit"), ergo everything in the Bible is infallible
truth, wholly complete and precise. Very simply, Camping asserts that the
Bible has the Salvation plan as its single message. If nothing in the Bible is
superfluous or erroneous and everything there exists to advance and corroborate
the message of the Gospel, then where God uses specific numbers rather than
generalizations, He does so with precision and purposeful intent - implying
their inclusion is often to convey a message by means of numeric symbolism.
The question of the infallibility of the Bible is large and complex, but it
presents an opportunity briefly to digress and present two puzzling biblical
inconsistencies.
Although God says "Let there be light," on the first day of creation, and
He says there is day and night, morning and evening thereafter, it is not until
the beginning of the fourth day that He creates "[two great] lights in the
expanse of the sky to separate the day from the night...[and] give light on the
earth." The stars are created almost as an afterthought. In defense of this,
Biblical literalists might suggest that between day one and day four, _God_ was
the light that separated day and night.
A second problem can be found in I Kings 7:23 and again in II Chronicles
4:2. In these passages which describe the construction of a circular bronze
basin in the Temple of Solomon, the ratio of a circle's circumference to its
diameter is implied to be the same as the ratio of 30 to 10. The implication
is that the value of pi is 3 - a value which is absolutely incorrect. (Please
see footnote). This is the kind of minutiae only a mathematician-historian
could love, but any diligent theologian could find. The error is excusable,
but only at great expense: if the figure has merely been rounded to the nearest
integer, then the Bible is not inerrant or at least not precise; since God is
infallible as is His Word, then these passages are heretical and possibly call
into question the authorship of other parts of the Bible; if you believe that
the Lord has purposely contrived the measurement, as He seems to contrive the
genealogies of Matthew 1 and Luke 3, then you must decide _why_ in the midst of
entire chapters of careful and exhaustive measurements for the construction of
Solomon's Temple God does so, and to make such a guess might violate the spirit
of II Peter 1:20 and II Timothy 3:16.
This particular defect actually has no bearing on the Bible's spiritual
message, unless your particular doctrine _depends_ upon the interpretation of
numbers and their inerrant use, as Mr. Camping's does.
NUMBERS: SYMBOLIC AND LITERAL
Where God uses numbers in other than a literal context, He unquestionably
is using them for some symbolic purpose. No argument there. The problem
arises when men like Harold Camping attempt to impose their own value-systems
on those numbers to derive their preposterous conclusions. The most well-known
symbolic equation in Christendom is unquestionably
Revelation 13:16 (NIV):
He also forced everyone, small and great, rich and
poor, free and slave, to receive a mark on his right
hand or on his forehead, so that no one could buy or
sell unless he had the mark, which is the name of
the beast or the number of his name.
This calls for wisdom. If anyone has insight,
let him calculate the number of the beast, for it is
man's number. His number is 666.
Various interpretations have been applied to explain the meaning of the
number. One Jehovah's Witness tract explains how 666 can be derived from any
Universal Product Code (UPC), bar-coded on products which we buy and sell. The
numerological system of Gematria has lead others at various times to believe
666 stood for the Roman emperor Nero, Domitian, Martin Luther, Pope Leo X,
former president Ronald Wilson Reagan and former Soviet president Mikhail
Gorbachev. (See "The New Merology of Beastly Numbers", pg 110, _Scientific
American_, March 1994).
A kind of cult mysticism has grown up around numbers in general, and
God's use of numbers in particular. Despite what Camping says -- "It is God's
plan that knowledge of His Word would increase near the end. Therefore, we
should not be surprised at what we are learning about the numbers God has
placed in the Bible," - deriving symbolic meanings from numbers in the Bible
is nothing new and Mr. Camping is certainly not the first to have thought of
it. The Hebrew Cabala is one of the best examples of a document which
endeavors to explain the numerology of the Old Testament. Similar treatises
exist in Islam for the Qur'an, and in the I Ching for Taoism.
HAROLD CAMPING'S NEW MEROLOGY: THE LANGUAGE OF PARABLES INCLUDES NUMBERS
Stories and announcements in the Bible are often told in the form of
parables. John the Baptist proclaims the coming of Christ with "Behold the
Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world." When you search the
Bible to discover the allegorical meaning of "Lamb of God" you learn that a
lamb is mentioned as a sacrificial animal; John's symbolic statement prefigures
Jesus' sacrifice at the crucifixion. Mr. Camping points out that God, by way
of John, could have said, "Behold the one who takes away the sin of the world,"
or "Behold my only son whom I will sacrifice for the sin of the world." God
does not, Camping says, because He intends to convey spiritual truth through
symbolic meaning. Camping continues by quoting Ephesians 1:5:
Having predestinated us unto the adoption of
children by Jesus Christ to himself, according
to the good pleasure of his will.
"This verse could have simply ended with the words 'according to His
will.' It would still be altogether a trustworthy phrase," says Camping. "The
addition of the words 'the good pleasure of' makes the verse much more
meaningful." Exactly what that additional meaning is, Camping does not say,
but his point is to suggest that, by extension, God's inclusion of specific
numbers makes the Gospel message more meaningful: "Likewise, God very
frequently uses numbers...to greatly enrich the spiritual content [of the
Gospel]."
How are we to learn God's symbolic meaning, His "additional truth" for
certain numbers?
We must, of course, interpret the meaning of
Biblical words and phrases by the way they are
used in the Bible. Likewise, we must understand
God's usage of the numbers recorded in the Bible
by the criteria that God Himself gives us in the
Bible.
In the same way that we discovered the meaning of "Lamb of God", by
reading the passages in which numbers are contained, Camping says we can derive
numbers' meaning through context and through association. "We are to determine
if there is a meaning that is a common thread that runs through the verses
wherein that number is used."
NUMEROLOGY IS EVIL
For example, the number 3 is used by itself (that is, not counting 33,
300, 3000, etc.) hundreds of times throughout the Bible -- in all but 11 books
of the Old Testament and all but 14 books of the New Testament. Camping notes
that the number figures prominently with the trial and crucifixion of Jesus:
1. There were three crosses (Luke 23:33)
2. Peter denied Jesus three times (Matthew 26:34, 75)
3. The inscription above the cross was written in three
languages (John 19:19-20, Luke 23:38)
4. Jesus prayed three times that this cup might
be removed (Matthew 26:39-44)
5. Three disciples went deeper into the garden
with Him (Matthew 26:36-37)
6. He was crucified the third hour (Mark 15:25)
7. There was darkness three hours (Mark 15:33)
...and so on. As to the symbolic significance of the number three,
Camping concludes:
Why does God repeatedly make reference to the
number 3 in connection with atonement? When we
carefully examine each of the above references,
we find that the emphasis signified by the use of
the number 3 is that of God's purpose. It was
God's purpose to pour out His wrath on Christ.
It was God's purpose that Jesus alone suffered
for our sins. It was God's purpose that He was
to be crucified so that it would be shown that
He had become cursed of God.
Furthermore, Camping adds: "Wherever the number 3 is in view, the truth
found in the event is enriched because we know that God is emphasizing that it
was His purpose to do whatever is recorded in the context in which that number
3 is found."
At which point, Mr. Camping makes a concerted effort to deceive the
reader:
...we must never engage in numerology,
as it is sometimes called. In this
practice, number values are assigned to the
letters of the Hebrew and Greek alphabets.
Thus, words and phrases are associated with each
other by their number values which are derived
from the number value of each letter in the word
or phrase. This practice has no Biblical
validation whatsoever. It is entirely alien to
the Bible and no Bible student who wishes to
find truth should have anything at all to do
with it.
Obviously, Harold Camping is making a deliberate attempt to misrepresent
the definition of numerology, because his citation is unquestionably incomplete
and skewed. Camping's purpose here is to distance his application of numbers
to the Bible from numerology - and no wonder! The practice of numerology has
fallen into ill repute, and reasonable people credit it with as much prophetic
integrity as biorhythms, daily horoscopes, and 1-900 psychic hotlines.
What he is referring to in the preceding quotation is the practice of
gematria, which is a particular kind of numerology. A complete definition of
numerology includes the attribution of occult or mystical significance to
numbers; bearing this in mind, Harold Camping's prime method of divination can
only be called numerology. The American Heritage English Dictionary defines
the word as follows:
Numerology (n): (1) Divination through numbers and
study of their occult significance and interrelation;
(2) A system of occultism built around numbers
especially [but not exclusively] those giving birth
dates, those which are the sum of the letters in
one's name, etc.; (3) Divination by numbers;
(4) The study of the occult meanings of numbers and
their supposed influence on human life.
Gematria's definition is difficult to find; even many encyclopedic
unabridged dictionaries fail to list it. Cassell's Concise English Dictionary
does, however:
Gematria (n): Cabbalistic system of interpreting
Hebrew Scriptures by interchanging words whose
letters have the same numerical value when added.
[Rabbinical Hebrew: gematriya; Greek: geometria - Geometry]
Biblical numerology has been practiced in one form or another for
centuries. _The Mystery of Numbers_ notes for instance: "Philo of Alexandria
combined ideas from the Old Testament and the Pythagorean tradition and thus
created the basis for the biblical exegesis of the Middle Ages, which is
heavily determined by number mysticism." Many of the previous predictions for
the Second Coming of Christ have depended upon these kinds of schemes.
ARE YOU READY FOR HAROLD CAMPING'S NUMEROLOGY?
In _Are You Ready?_, Camping arranges his numerological symbols in
numerical order. However, since many of his symbols seem to have similar
meanings, we have arranged them by synonymity. With each numerological symbol,
Camping gives a few examples which provide the context and 'validity' for the
equation of the symbol with its meaning.
2 SIGNIFIES THE CHURCH, either as a corporate, external body or as the
true believers within the church.
1. Two witnesses (Revelation 11:3).
2. Two olive trees (Revelation 11:4).
3. Two candlesticks (Revelation 11:4).
4. They were sent out two by two (Mark 6:7).
3 SIGNIFIES THE PURPOSE OR WILL OF GOD
1. The number 3 is tremendously prominent in the atonement:
3 days and nights; 3 crosses; Jesus prayed 3 times;
Peter denied Jesus 3 times, etc.
2. Paul prayed 3 times for the removal of the thorn in the
flesh (II Corinthians 12:7-8).
4 SIGNIFIES UNIVERSALITY
1. Points of the compass (Revelation 21:13).
2. Revelation 17:5 (peoples, multitudes, nations, tongues).
3. Revelation 20:8 (nations in the four quarters of the earth).
5 SIGNIFIES GOD'S GRACE (Salvation or redemption) [ Version 1 ]
1. Matthew 25:2, five wise virgins.
2. Numbers 18:16, five shekels were given as redemption money.
3. The five loaves that fed the five thousand (Matthew 16:9).
8 SIGNIFIES REDEMPTION OR SALVATION
1. Babies circumcised on the eighth day (Gen 17:12)
2. Eight persons in the ark (I Peter 3:20)
3. Jesus was raised on the eighth day. (The first day of the
week became the eighth day when added to the previous seven
days.)
17 SIGNIFIES HEAVEN OR SALVATION
1. Joseph was 17 years old when he had the dream that the
members of his family would bow before him. In view of
the fact that Joseph was a type or figure of Christ, this
event anticipates heaven when all believers will worship
Christ (Gen. 37:2-10).
2. Jacob lived seventeen years in Egypt under the care and
keeping of Joseph who as the second ruler of Egypt had saved
him from the famine. This event points us to heaven which
we obtain when we have come under the care and keeping of
Christ forevermore (Gen. 47:28).
3. When Israel was about to go into captivity, Jeremiah was
instructed to buy a field in the land of Israel and pay
seventeen shekels for it (Jeremiah 32:9). This anticipates
the future return of Israel into the land of Israel
which in turn is a figure of our entrance into heaven or
into salvation (Jeremiah 32:37-38).
5 SIGNIFIES THE JUDGMENT OF GOD [ Version 2 ]
1. The five foolish virgins (Matthew 25:2-12)
2. The five brothers who were still under the judgment
of God (Luke 16:28)
3. The five months of Revelation 9:5 signifying God's judgment
on the Church.
23 SIGNIFIES JUDGMENT
1. The 2300 days when the temple is trodden under foot which
points to the final tribulation period when God is judging
the church (Daniel 8:13-14).
2. The 23,000 who were killed in the plague
(I Corinthians 10:8).
3. The twenty-three years inclusively which began with the
death of the last good king over Judah. His name was Josiah
and he was killed in battle in the year 609 BC. The
remaining four kings were very wicked but reigned until
587 BC when Judah was completely destroyed by
the Babylonians.
37 SIGNIFIES JUDGMENT
1. Jehoiachin freed by the king of Babylon in his
thirty-seventh year (II Kings 25:27). This event points
to the judgment on the church at the end of the world.
2. David, who typifies Christ, had thirty-seven mighty men
who fought the enemies of Israel (II Samuel 23:39). These
thirty-seven men typify the believers as they bring the
Gospel which emphasizes that man is under judgment and who
with Christ will judge the world at the end of time.
3. The number of man -- 666 -- equals 3 * 6 * 37. This
signifies spiritually that it is God's purpose (3) that
those who work (6) to get right with God (this includes
everyone who is not saved), will come into judgment (37).
4. Noah and his family were in the ark 370 days (Gen. 7:11, 24;
8:4, 14-18). This is 10 * 37. it signifies that they
remained in the safety of the ark until God's judgment (37)
upon the earth had been completed (10). Or we could say:
Because they were in the safety of the ark, they
completely (10) escaped the judgment (37) of God.
5. 185,000 Assyrians who assaulted Judah in Hezekiah's reign
were killed by God in one night (II Kings 19:35).
185,000 = 5 * 37 * 10 * 10 * 10. This signifies God's
complete (10 * 10) judgment (37) upon the wicked who come
against God's kingdom, which consists of those who are
completely (10) saved (5).
6 SIGNIFIES WORK
1. Creation. "For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth"
(Exodus 20:11).
2. Six days work (Exodus 20:9).
3. Six years planting (Exodus 23:10).
4. Christ works to provide for our redemption (Luke 23:44,
John 19:14-18).
7 SIGNIFIES PERFECTION OR TOTALITY
1. Seven days of creation.
2. The seven spirits of God (Revelation 5:6).
3. The seven heads of the dragon (Revelation 13:1).
4. The seven churches (Revelation 1:4).
10 (OR 100 OR 1000) SIGNIFIES THE COMPLETENESS OF WHATEVER IS IN VIEW
1. The ten commandments (Exodus 20).
2. The ten virgins (Matthew 25:1).
3. The ten coins (Luke 15:8).
4. The 100 sheep (Luke 15:4).
5. The 1000 years (Revelation 20:1-5).
12 SIGNIFIES THE FULLNESS OF WHATEVER IS IN VIEW
1. The twelve tribes of Israel (James 1:1).
2. The twelve apostles (Mark 3:14).
3. The holy city Jerusalem has twelve foundations and
twelve gates, etc. (Revelation 21:14,21).
13 SIGNIFIES THE SUPERFULLNESS OR END OF THE WORLD
1. While twelve tribes are normally featured, there were in
fact thirteen tribes.
2. While twelve apostles are normally featured in the Bible,
the Apostle Paul insists that he was an apostle like
the others (II Corinthians 12:11-12, I Corinthians 9:1,
I Corinthians 15:8-9).
3. Israel went around the walls of Jericho thirteen times
before the walls fell (Joshua 6).
11 SIGNIFIES THE COMING OF CHRIST AS SAVIOR
1. The eleven brothers will bow down to Joseph who is a type
of Christ (Genesis 37:9).
2. The eleven days' journey of Deuteronomy 1:2.
3. The eleven sons of Jacob who were born in Haran but who
came with Jacob into Canaan (Genesis 32:22).
40 SIGNIFIES TESTING
1. Israel was forty years in the wilderness as God tested them
whether they would obey Him (Deuteronomy 8:2-3, 15-16).
2. Jesus was forty days in the wilderness being tested
(Luke 4:2).
3. Jesus remained on earth forty days before His ascension.
This signifies a test for mankind as to whether they will
believe on Him as the risen Christ (Acts 1:3).
CAMPING'S LANGUAGE OF NUMBERS
How does Camping account for other numbers, numbers larger than 40?
"...when they are broken down [factored] to their prime numbers, by means of
the spiritual truth latent within each prime number, the spiritual message (if
any is intended by it) is revealed." This is true, he says, especially of
"[large] numbers in the Bible that are found only once and yet...are in a very
significant context."
Of the prime numbers 19, 29, 31, 41 and greater, Camping says "at present
sufficient Biblical information has not been found to understand their
spiritual meaning (if any has been intended by God)." It would seem God
prefers composite numbers (numbers which can be factored) to primes.
Congratulations for having gotten this far! This is where the really
interesting stuff begins; the key to Mr. Camping's prophecy is factoring
"Biblically significant" numbers into the products of his spiritually
significant numbers then constructing ad-lib sentences based on the result.
Let's discover what spiritual truth is conveyed by the number 666. There
are four unique ways to factor 666; only two of them are composed entirely of
numbers found in Camping's numerology, and only one of those produces a result
consistent with his preconceived beliefs. Mr. Camping chooses to factor 666
into its "significant numbers" as follows:
3 * 6 * 37 = 666
3 signifies the purpose or will of God
6 signifies work
37 signifies the judgment of God
Mr. Camping explains:
Remember, 6 is a number that signifies work. It
points to those who are working for their salvation.
That includes each and every human being who is
not saved. By nature, because they were created
in the image of God, they want somehow to become
right with God. But in their rebellion and pride,
every idea fostered in man's mind includes the
concept that man must do something himself to be
right with God. He must live in such a way or do
such a thing that God will recognize their
worthiness and save them. ... this number signifies
that it is God's purpose or will (3) to bring to
judgment (37) all those who are trusting in
their own works (6) to become saved.
Example after example, Mr. Camping goes through the Bible finding
important passages that contain numbers, factoring those numbers as he chooses,
then constructing spiritually significant sentences which dove-tail nicely with
his non-numerological interpretations of the passages. Each spiritually
significant sentence is sufficiently vague as to be applicable as Camping's
desires see fit. The sheer number of examples Mr. Camping supplies which
evidence prophetic results is supposed to convince you that Camping's
methodology is indeed the key to God's prophecy and per force circular
reasoning, the numerological results are correct because the methodology is!
THE LANGUAGE OF CAMPING'S NUMBERS IS LIMITED
If an analysis of the Bible emphasized only of a handful of words, such
as: sparrow, hawk, eagle, turkey, penguin, and ostrich, then it wouldn't be
surprising if the results sounded predominantly aviary in nature. These
investigations into works of scripture would not exactly inspire awe and
terror, and would largely be ignored.
Likewise, if your numerological vocabulary was limited to 16 words and
phrases, like 'End of the World', 'Coming of Christ as Savior', 'Judgment' or
'Will of God', you shouldn't be surprised if everything derived from this
numerological language seemed prophetic. After all, if the entirety of your
source material is a discussion of God's will and impending judgment of the
Earth, you shouldn't be surprised if the end product of your efforts yields
ominous results. God In equals God Out. This is much more in line with
Camping's methodology.
Merely because Camping's method of factoring numbers can result in ad-hoc
sentences which ring prophetic proves nothing about the nature of the number,
its use in the Bible or for that matter, the time-frame for the end of the
world.
KORAH, DATHAN AND ABIRAM: CAMPING'S NUMEROLOGY IN ACTION
On page 199 of _Are you Ready?_, Camping discusses "another account that
beautifully illustrates the principle that God frequently introduces numbers"
to numerologically emphasize a message: the rebellion of Korah, Dathan and
Abiram against Moses in Numbers 16.
Korah son of Izhar, the son of Kohath, the son of
Levi, and certain Reubenites -- Dathan and Abiram,
sons of Eliab, and On son of Peleth -- became
insolent and rose up against Moses. With them
were 250 Israelite men, well-known community
leaders who had been appointed members of the
council.
As a consequence of rebellion, God causes the earth to open up and
swallow Korah, Dathan, Abiram and their families in Numbers 16:31:
As soon as he finished saying all this, the
ground under them split apart and the earth
opened its mouth and swallowed them, with
their households and all Korah's men and all
their possessions.
Of the 250 well-known members of the community also aligned with Korah,
Dathan and Abiram, we read in Numbers 16:35:
And fire came out from the Lord and consumed
the 250 men who were offering incense.
The following day, the Israelites complained to God, saying that Moses
and Aaron had killed the people of the Lord. God answers this new insurrection
by sending a plague into the Israelites, a plague whose deadly force is stayed
only after Aaron's intervention. Numbers 16:48:
He stood between the living and the dead, and
the plague stopped. But 14,700 people died
from the plague, in addition to those who had
died because of Korah.
Camping interprets:
"In this account, rebellious Israel is representative
of all mankind who have rebelled against God. The plague
that killed a great many of the Israelites and the fire
that came down and destroyed 250 men are pointing to the
judgment of God that will destroy all of the unsaved.
The atonement offered by Aaron as well as Aaron himself,
as he stood between the dead and the living, represent
Christ Himself..."
"Why did God give us this information [the quantity of the dead]? Why
didn't He simply declare that a great number of people died in the plague? Why
did He number the princes of the people who rebelled against Moses and were
killed by fire from heaven? Why does He bring these two numbers together in
verse 49?" By this, Camping means to infer spiritual significance from God's
use of numbers and suggests that this Biblical account prefigures the end
times.
Camping then adds the 250 men who died by fire from heaven to the 14,700
who perished in the plague and arrives at the figure 14,950. He breaks this
number down into its prime or significant numbers as follows:
14,950 = 5 * 10 * 13 * 23
5 signifies salvation or judgment
10 signifies completeness
13 signifies the end of the world
23 signifies judgment
Camping asserts that "fire from heaven signifies the judgment of God
that is to come on the unsaved at the end of the world," and that the Korah,
Dathan, Abiram rebellion is an allegory of "God's final judgment on the enemies
of God (the unsaved) as they are cast into hellfire on the last day. ... The
14,950 people who are numbered in this Numbers account are a picture of those
who will endure the judgment of God on the last day." Camping then concludes
that the spiritually-significant 14,950 reinforces this truth:
Those who rebel against God are under the
judgment (5) of God and will experience the
complete (10) judgment (23) of God at the
end of the world (13).
One problem, however, with Camping's interpretation is that his addition
is wrong. His 14,950 figure fails to include the antagonists of this Biblical
episode, namely Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, (and what about the unnumbered
members of their households?) who are killed in Numbers 16:31! By our count,
3 + 250 + 14,700 = 14,953. And, unfortunately for Camping, 14,953 is the
product of two prime numbers - 19 and 787 - neither of which are addressed
by his 'Biblically-inspired' numerology.
IV. SIGNIFICANT BIBLICAL TIME-PATHS POINT TO 1994
----------- -------- ---- ----- ----- -- ----
"Everything fits together so precisely!"
-- Harold Camping, _Are You Ready?_,
commenting on the Bible's time-paths
to the year 1994. Pg 218.
Since God has given sufficient information so that
we can reconstruct the calendar of history [an
exercise Camping performs earlier in _Are You
Ready?_], how is the Gospel message enhanced and
enriched by the numbers that describe the passage
of time?
Through a process we can only guess at, Harold Camping has already
decided the year of the second coming. For him, the task remains to collect
'evidence' to prove it _deductively_. Seek, with enough conviction
aforethought, and ye shall find.
In the eighth and ninth chapters of _Are You Ready?_, Mr. Camping selects
forty-nine Biblical "calendar milestones" - passages which prefigure the end
times - which he has carefully dated. (He selects forty-nine examples probably
because forty-nine is seven times seven - seven being the number for perfection
or totality.) He then calculates the elapsed years from those dates to
Christ's birth in 7 BC, His crucifixion in AD 33, the Tribulation (which
Camping says began in 1988), and Christ's second coming in 1994. Working
backwards from his desired result, Camping factors the differences yielded by
his scheme and discovers spiritually significant messages. This is how he
proves that we now have merely days left before the return of Christ.
As we continue our study of the Bible, we will
find that the time paths from significant
historical events to Christ's first coming or
to His second coming may have great spiritual
meaning. When the total number of years
between the event in question and the first or
second coming of Christ is broken down to its
significant or prime numbers, and the spiritual
meaning inherent within these significant or
prime numbers is applied to the passage in
which the larger number is found, the Gospel
is enriched and enhanced. ... give[s] further
evidence that the year AD 1988 indeed must be
the year when the final tribulation did begin,
and the year AD 1994 must be the year of Christ's
return.
All this despite that Camping had earlier admonished against deductive
reasoning:
I Corinthians 2:13:
Which things also we speak, not in the words which
man's wisdom teacheth, but which the Holy Ghost
teacheth; comparing spiritual things with spiritual."
In this statement God rejects the idea that we can
interpret the Scriptures to make them agree with
what we have in our minds or our denominational
doctrine.
Mr. Camping's method is flawed from the outset; the question of 1994
being the date for the end of the world was a premise the data were supposed
to test, not rest upon.
GOD IS PRECISE
According to Mr. Camping, all of the numbers in the scriptures were
recorded by God, and each of those numbers He gave us are elements of coded
messages.
Included in these words that were God-breathed are
all of the numbers found in the Bible. They are just
as important and just as much the Word of God as any
other word recorded in the Bible.
God may be precise, but concerning His numerological missives, they
certainly lack the sort of self-evident data integrity that Camping implies.
If Camping's method were valid, then only certain numbers would produce
intelligible results, while anything else should generate meaningless
gobbledygook.
There are two ways of demonstrating the falsity of his method in this
regard.
1. Take composite numbers he has gleaned from his
investigations and demonstrate the broad domain of
possible interpretations for each set of factors.
2. Factor numbers which appear nowhere in the Bible
and compare the messages with similar ones of Camping's.
For instance, let's pretend the Bible is describing a man born in 1890 AD
who probably has bearing on the Second Coming. Let's also pretend that we
concur with Camping that the end of the world is due in 1994.
There are 104 years between 1890 and 1994. We have chosen to factor 104
into 13 * 4 * 2.
2 signifies the true believers
4 signifies universality
13 signifies superfullness or the end of the world
Did this man's birth have anything significant to do with the armies of
Gog and Magog meeting on the field of Armageddon? The numbers seem to indicate
that this man's birth prefigures: the end of the world (13) coming for the
entire world (4) full of true believers (2).
This is actually pretty interesting, because Camping's method has managed
to teach us something we didn't know: the birth of H.P. Lovecraft (1890-1937)
was an important and demonstrable sign of the second coming of
Christ.
Let's return to Camping's interpretation of the spiritual truth conveyed
by the number 666. We mentioned earlier that, of the four unique ways to
factor 666,
18 * 37 = 666
2 * 9 * 37 = 666
3 * 6 * 37 = 666
2 * 3 * 3 * 37 = 666
Only half of them are composed entirely of numbers found in Camping's
numerology. Camping chooses 3 * 6 * 37 to illustrate that the number of the
beast signifies:
it is God's purpose or will (3) to bring to
judgment (37) all those who are trusting in
their own works (6) to become saved.
What if we choose to factor 666 as:
666 = 3 * 3 * 2 * 37
2 signifies the true believers
3 signifies purpose or will of God
37 signifies judgment
It is _truly_ God's purpose or will (3 * 3) to
save the true believers (2) from judgment (37).
Can the number of the beast indicate deliverance for the true believers?
Camping's scheme generated both decrees. Is there an attribute that the first
message has that's lacking in ours? Yes, there is: Harold Camping wrote the
first one and not the second.
Apart from the difference in authorship, there can be no way of
determining which product of hermeneutics accurately represents God's intended
message. Therefore, God's chosen means of hidden communication has turned out
to be vague to the point of uselessness, assuming God indeed buried these
messages in the first place.
Mr. Camping may argue that our result has been taken out of context
(something he is not unfamiliar with) and is therefore invalid, but in doing
so, Mr. Camping would reveal yet another flaw in his numerology: that finding
the correct result requires projecting your beliefs into his method ahead of
time. It isn't infallible truth if it requires fallible man to sift and
interpret it.
AMBIGUITY PROCLUDES A DEFINITE MEANING
According to Camping's theory, God is implying a very definite message
through the numbers in the Bible - specifically, the date of the end of the
world.
Another way of saying this is that God has hidden the date within the
wide variety of numbers encountered in the scriptures. For the means of
arriving at the date to be in keeping with the authority of the Ten
Commandments, the scheme would have to point to a specific number and none
other.
This is not the sort of system Camping employs. Nowhere do we come across
an instance in which his interpretation of a composite number is clearly the
only one possible, even after granting him the extreme latitude of pronouncing
what each of the factors means in his system.
Let's return to Camping's numerological Rosetta Stone to pose a few
questions:
(1) Why are there so many synonymous numerological symbols? Five,
six and seventeen all signify salvation? Five, twenty-three,
and thirty-seven all signify judgment? Why does
10 = 100 = 1000? With so many synonymous numerological
symbols, the precision God is credited with is not advanced
(since there is less distinction and more synonymity), so
any great message God is communicating is watered down
by such a system.
(2) If the spiritual meaning of a particular number is derived
by the context in which it is used, then why doesn't the
number two represent the animal kingdom? (Two of every
unclean animal went into the Ark).
(3) As to the number three, Camping says "Indeed, wherever we
find the number 3 used anywhere in the Bible, IF IT
SIGNIFIES SPIRITUAL TRUTH, it will be emphasizing God's
purpose." The entire Gospel of the Bible emphasizes God's
purpose! What does God do that _isn't_ His will or
purpose?! When does something in the Bible _not_ signify
spiritual truth in one way or another? Why is Harold
Camping the arbiter of spiritual truth? Camping goes
to great length to remind us that God moved men of old to
write everything, and that God is very particular about
everything in the Bible, but somehow, sometimes something
doesn't signify spiritual truth?
(4) After an exhaustive computer search of the Bible for every
occurrence of the number 37 by itself (that is,
not counting 137, 637, etc.), we find exactly _two_ occurrences,
both of which are named by Camping. The number 37 could not
have stood out to Camping by the sheer number of occurrences.
More probably, Camping found 37 occurring as a factor
in larger numbers and needed 37 to mean 'judgment'. In
particular, he would need 37 to mean judgment for his
evaluation of 666 - one of the first numbers he factors
in his book. This would also seem to explain why there
are three numbers in Camping's symbology which all mean
'judgment'.
Since a list of only two examples for the number 37 would
not be very persuasive, Camping relies on circular logic
for his three remaining examples, factoring 666, 370
and 185,000 and pointing to their subsequent
interpretations as proof that 37 = judgment.
(5) How can five signify two antithetical ideas - salvation
_and_ judgment? And when are we to know which idea
God intends? The difference could be crucial.
Interestingly, in Camping's examples wherever there is
one instance of five, there is usually a second instance;
Camping makes use of the opportunity to provide some
kind of numero-spiritual parity.
(6) When deconstructing the value of 666, Camping says,
"Remember, 6 is a number that signifies work. It
points to those who are working for their salvation."
The construction of Camping's numerology relies on
connotation; in Camping's table of numbers, 6 has
a positive connotation -- the Lord created the universe
in six days; Christ working to provide for our
redemption, etc. And yet Camping uses 6 in a
negatively-connoted way to reveal the meaning of 666.
The number 6 as a factor is one of the rarest in
Camping's book. Though a factor of 6 can be extracted
from most of the spiritually significant large
numbers in his book, he chooses to do so in only three
instances: the evaluation of 666, a variation of
that evaluation used on pg 276, and the assumption
of Nebuchadrezzar to the Babylonian throne. The
last example notwithstanding, Camping seems to have
specifically designed 6 to meet his needs for
uncovering the spiritual truth latent in 666.
(7) Completeness of whatever is in view? Fullness?
Superfullness?! Super-abundant fullness?!
GOD'S TIME-LINE IS IN EFFECT
Camping selects forty-nine Biblical episodes related to the Gospel message
or the fulfillment of the Gospel program. He refers to these episodes as
"calendar milestones." Through a process which is not always clear, he has
dated each event; for instance, Abraham's son Isaac - whom Abraham is told to
sacrifice on an altar - is said to have been born in 2067 BC. How Camping
arrived at these dates or whether they are even correct is not important in
evaluating Camping's methodology, however. (If the reader does a little
checking, he will find several of Camping's dates cannot be correct.)
Because God provides Mr. Camping enough corroborative evidence to date
these episodes and reconstruct the "Biblical calendar", Camping infers the
calendar can be projected forward into the future and that God will provide
corroborative evidence - through numerology - that 1994 is the end of the
world. Using his own form of logic, Mr. Camping suggests that if the elapsed
years between each of these events and the coming of Christ
1. At Christ's birth in 7 BC
2. At Christ's crucifixion in AD 33
3. At Christ's second coming, beginning
with the Tribulation in AD 1988
4. At Christ's coming on the last day in AD 1994
is calculated and factored, and if those factors result in a spiritually
significant message that (a) there is a relationship between the end of the
world and these milestones which are said to prefigure it, and (b) that 1994
is in all likelihood the end of the world.
As you scan the 54 pages in which Mr. Camping lays out the evaluation of
the forty-nine calendar milestones, two things become immediately obvious:
1. In no instance does Mr. Camping compare all four
of the dates related to Christ's coming (above)
against a milestone. Occasionally he
selects three of the dates related to Christ
to compare against the milestone; sometimes he
selects only one of the dates related to Christ,
but Mr. Camping never factors the difference between
any calendar milestone and _all four_ of the dates
that relate to Christ's coming.
2. When evaluating the number that results from the
difference between the date of the milestone and
a date related to Christ's coming, Camping often
factors that number in several ways, suggesting
all of them are valid interpretations and
because there are several ways to interpret the
same number, God is really trying to give us the
hint!
Why doesn't Camping compare all four dates related to Christ's coming
against each milestone? Let's look at milestone number one. (Remember that in
figuring the elapsed years between a BC date and an AD date, you must subtract
one year, since there is no year 0 AD.)
Event No. 1
Creation: 11,013 BC
RELATIONSHIP OF THE EVENT TO THE GOSPEL MESSAGE:
In the year 11,013 BC, God created the earth
and the whole universe. This was the first event
required to bring to pass God's Gospel plan.
TIME LINE. Years to the end of the world, AD 1988:
11,013 + 1988 - 1 = 13,000 years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,000 years = 13 * 1000.
God's Gospel plan, which began with creation
(11,013 BC), will be brought to completion (1000)
at the end of the world (13). The end of the world
begins with the final tribulation (AD 1988), as God
prepares the church and the world for Judgment Day.
OR: TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,000 years = 4 * 5 * 5 * 10 * 13.
God's Gospel of salvation (5) and judgment (5)
for the whole world (4) will be completed (10) at
the end of the world (13). The end of the world
begins with the final tribulation which prepares
the world for judgment.
OR: TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,000 years = 5 * 5 * 13 * 40.
God's plan of testing (40), which results
in either salvation (5) or judgment (5), goes
all the way to the end of the world (13). The
end of the world begins with the final tribulation
as judgment begins with the house of God.
OR: TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,000 years = 2 * 2 * 5 * 5 * 10 * 13.
It is established by God will [sic] shortly
come to pass (2 * 2) that God will complete (10)
His Gospel of salvation (5) and judgment (5)
at the end of time (13) beginning with the final
tribulation period which prepares the world for the
end.
For a moment, let's digress on the glaring issue of Camping's date for the
creation: 11,013 BC. Despite that Harold Camping frequently refers to science
and scientific fact to corroborate his beliefs,
...we must remember that the same all-wise God
who wrote the Bible also created the universe.
As we examine the atoms, the molecules, the
neutrons, the protons, etc., that are all
integral parts of creation, we know that God's
use of numbers is found everywhere. Everything,
down to the smallest particle of matter, is
precisely designed by God according to very
precise number systems.
...
If scientists were to disregard all usage of numbers
in their study of the universe, their understanding
would be seriously hampered. Numbers have a tremendous
involvement in the design of the universe.
he chooses to completely disregard well-founded scientific conclusions when
it's convenient. Mr. Camping maintains that, in so far as science's
disagreements with his theories, "...scientific conclusions are not even a
fraction as accurate as the majestic statements of the Bible." The truth is,
Mr. Camping's pseudo-scientific conclusions are only a fraction as accurate as
secular science's. In a radio program broadcast on Saturday, July 23rd,
Camping repeatedly referred to the speed of light as 156,000 miles per second
- a figure 30,000 miles per second too slow. (We wonder what this civil
engineer-turned-minister would have to say about the value of pi...)
The world is older than 13,000 years. The same all-wise God that created
the universe seems to have given us the fossil record as well. At nearly 3.5
million years, Lucy (the name given to A. afarensis remains discovered in
Ethiopia in 1974) is certainly much older than Camping's date. The rocks in
your backyard are probably older than 13,000 years! Even if for some reason
you refuse to believe in radio-metric dating methods and everything those
methods depend on, you need only visit Greenland. There you will find ice
cores a mile deep in which you can very distinctly count over 200,000 winters.
The Hebrew calendar in use today, on which Mr. Camping depends for the
Jubilee Year, begins at the creation, which is calculated to have occurred
3,760 years before the Christian era. So at the very least, there is some
disagreement between Camping and the Jews, whose information he often depends
upon.
Back to Camping's time-line. Why didn't Camping compare 11,013 BC against
the dates for Christ's birth, Christ's crucifixion or 1994? Let's look at the
math:
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's birth, 7 BC:
11,013 + 7 - 1 = 11,019 years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
11,019 years = 3 * 3673.
It is God's purpose or will (3) that you not factor 11,019.
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's crucifixion, AD 33:
11,013 + 33 - 1 = 11,045 years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
11,045 years = 5 * 2209.
God will save (5) you from factoring this number, too.
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's second coming, AD 1994:
11,013 + 1994 - 1 = 13,006 years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,006 years = 2 * 7 * 929.
God's true believers (2) think Mr. Camping's method of prophecy is less
than perfect (7).
What does Mr. Camping have to say about the numerological messages which
result from the comparisons between the dates for Christ's comings and the
calendar milestones? Why does he now illustrate several ways to factor the
same number?
Please bear in mind that the spiritual emphasis
brought...by the number pattern is suggestive.
With an understanding of the spiritual significance
of each event together with the number that is
hidden within the time paths, it might be possible
to write somewhat different sentences that are still
in harmony with the Gospel.
Two hundred fifty seven pages into his book, logic has begun to take its
toll on Mr. Camping, and he has begun to capitulate. According to Mr. Camping,
now it's no longer important that a specific message intended by God result
from Biblical passages, hence his various interpretations for each milestone.
As long as something _intelligible_ results, that's corroborative evidence! So
much for God's definite message and the lesson of "...according to the good
pleasure of his will"!
IMAGINE A CALENDAR WITH YEAR 0
In 1975, Pol Pot introduced year 0 to Cambodia. Aside from that instance,
calendars have not included a year zero. This is the case partially because it
makes less sense to start with year zero (resulting in a discrepancy between
the cardinal and ordinal order of your calendar) than it does year one and
partially because the number 0 is a relatively new concept. In _Beyond
Numeracy_, John Allen Paulos explains:
...we note that about 2,000 years ago the Chinese
invented a written positional numeration system
based on powers of 10. About 500 years later
the people of southern India independently
made the same discovery, but soon thereafter went
further and invented zero ... The Chinese
borrowed the notion of zero from the Indians, as
did the Arabs, who eventually communicated the
whole system to Western Europe.
With zero an unknown concept to the Romans, the Julian calendar (on which
our current Gregorian calendar is based) could not have had a year zero. Mr.
Camping has a different perspective on history:
Everything, down to the smallest particle of
matter, is precisely designed by God according
to very precise number systems. ... Was it
accidental that the Julian calendar, which
became the Gregorian calendar, when projected
back to the very beginning, starts out with the
year 11,013 BC? [What is Camping talking about?]
Was it accidental that this calendar left out
the year 0 so that two paths are possible -
the calendar path and the actual path - to such
great events as the cross and the second coming
of Christ? Was it accidental that Jesus was born
in 7 BC rather than the year 0 or the year AD 1?
Was it accidental that Christ was born on Christmas? The facts answer for
themselves!
...
God has doubled the possibility of significant
time paths by allowing or guiding the designer
of the Julian calendar to leave out the year 0.
What does Camping mean by "doubled the possibility of significant time
paths"? Let's look at an example: the birth of Isaac, son of Abraham, in
2067 BC.
Camping says Isaac's near-sacrifice on an altar prefigures God's sacrifice
of His son Jesus (hence Isaac's birth-date becomes significant to Camping).
When we look at the time relationship - the elapsed years - between Isaac's
birth and the crucifixion, we find:
2067 + 33 - 1 = 2099 years
Two thousand ninety-nine is a prime number, and so neither God nor Camping
can factor it into a spiritually significant message. Camping momentarily
concludes, "Therefore, this is not a significant or important time period." At
this point, Camping invents a make-believe time-unit called the 'calendar year'
to work around the problem and credits God with the concept:
But [2099] is a significant time period when
we calculate the passage of time in calendar
years instead of in actual years. To arrive
at actual years in calculating the passage
of time requires the subtraction of one
year in going from an Old Testament event
to a New Testament event. This is because the
calendar does not include a year 0. ...
Had the calendar been designed with a year
zero, ... [one would calculate] the actual
years between an Old Testament event and a
New Testament event...by simply adding the
Old Testament [date] to the New Testament [date].
This is an especially useful discovery on Mr. Camping's part because for
any prime number p, greater than 2, (p + 1) is not prime. (Camping's thinking
must go something like this: if I can propose a method whose results I like,
then the method is acceptable and logical, the result of God's inspiration.)
God could simply have chosen to use non-primes (ie, composite numbers) in the
Biblical time-line, but instead He does something much less simple: He allows
us the luxury of using a calendar with a year 0 whenever it's convenient. We
now have the divine authority to add one year (to cancel out the subtraction
of a year) to an elapsed actual year if the elapsed actual year is a prime
number. Mercifully, Camping resorts to using "calendar years" when he
absolutely needs to, otherwise his book might be 800 pages long instead of
400. Nevertheless, Camping makes use of "calendar years" 27 times throughout
the evaluations of his 49 calendar milestones.
Why doesn't Mr. Camping apply calendar years in Event No. 1, the creation
in 11,013 BC?
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's birth, 7 BC:
11,013 + 7 = 11,020 calendar years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
11,020 calendar years = 2 * 5 * 38 * 29.
Mr. Camping's true believers (2) have not reached a judgment (5) on what
to do with 38 and 29.
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's crucifixion, AD 33:
11,013 + 33 = 11,046 calendar years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
11,046 calendar years = 6 * 7 * 263.
Mr. Camping will have to work (6) harder than this to perfect (7) his
scheme.
TIME LINE. Years to Christ's second coming, AD 1994:
11,013 + 1994 = 13,007 calendar years.
TIME LINE'S SPIRITUAL EMPHASIS:
13,007 calendar years = prime number.
A prime number. Doh!
Additionally, Mr. Camping sometimes chooses not to compare a particular
date related to Christ against a milestone so that he can later point to a
beautiful symmetry whose implications are... compelling:
We can be quite certain that 7 BC is the year in
which Jesus was born. We can also be absolutely
certain that AD 33 was the year Christ was
crucified. We must, therefore, be quite impressed
by the fact that there are about the same number
of paths (sixteen) to the year AD 1988 as there are
to the birth of Christ in 7 BC (seventeen). In
each case these are separate and distinct paths.
Equally impressive is the fact that there
are twenty-six paths to the year AD 1994 and
twenty-six paths to AD 33. Surely this should
emphasize very strongly the likelihood of the end
of the world coming in AD 1994.
Surely it doesn't.
CHOICES, CHOICES, CHOICES...
What does Camping do when a spiritually significant number results in
multiple instances of the same factor? For instance, pg 251:
But when 3960 is broken down to prime and significant
numbers, many spiritual truths are in evidence.
Let us look first at 3960 years = 3 * 3 * 2 * 2 * 10 * 11.
According to Camping, when God doubles a factor, He is _emphasizing_ some
part of His message. With regard to the above example, Camping explains:
Three signifies purpose and 3 * 3 further emphasizes
this purpose. We could say it is God's _definite_
purpose that Christ will come as Savior.
The number 2 * 2 is featured. Since 2 is the number
signifying the church or believers and a doubling
of the number gives it added emphasis, we can
understand that God has in mind that God is teaching
that the church very definitely will be brought into
existence before the end of the world.
This is a convenient, if ludicrous explanation. Evidently Camping evolved
it a little more than half-way through his book. Earlier, on pg 198, Camping
merely ignored multiple instances of the same factor:
If we apply the same principle, of breaking down
a larger number to its significant or prime numbers,
to the 153 fish of John 21:11, we find that:
153 = 3 * 3 * 17.
The number 3 signifies purpose whereas the
number 17 signifies heaven or salvation. Since
Jesus told His disciples, "I will make you fishers
of men" (Matthew 4:19), we can understand that the
153 large fish caught in the net signify all those
who will become saved. That is, it signifies
that the purpose of God (3) is to bring all those
caught in the net of the Gospel to heaven or
to salvation (17).
A conspicuous exception to Camping's rule of emphasis is the occurrence
of 5 * 5. In almost every instance, Camping makes use of 5's double entendre:
9100 = 7 * 13 * 4 * 5 * 5. These numbers suggest
that: At the end of the world (13) in a perfect
way (7) the whole world (4) will either experience
the judgment of God (5) or the salvation of God (5).
Page 251 of _Are You Ready?_ gives the most entertaining example of
Camping's rule of emphasis:
2835 years = 3 * 3 * 3 * 3 * 5 * 7
It is God's _absolute_ purpose (3 * 3 * 3 * 3)
that perfect (7) judgment (5) will come upon the
church at the end of time [Emphasis added].
The set of composite numbers which can be factored entirely by Camping's
Rosetta Stone of 16 significant numbers is therefore infinite. Since doubling
(or quadrupling...) a factor emphasizes it, then the figure of 2835 years
mentioned above is symbolically the same as 2835 * 3, which is the same as 2835